Visy loses appeal over call back rates for staff who volunteered for pre-shift overtime

Visy workers who put their names down for overtime and are rung after leaving work to come in early must be paid call back rates. A Full Bench of the Fair Work Commission dismissed Visy’s appeal, finding a request the employee agrees to is enough, with no greater compulsion required.

4 min read
FWC Full Bench
Share this storyLinkedInWhatsAppTeamsFacebookX

An employee who marks themselves available for overtime, leaves work, and then agrees to a supervisor’s request to come back early has been “called back” to work and is owed call back rates. A Full Bench of the Fair Work Commission put its answer bluntly: “The answer to that question is yes.”

Visy Board Pty Ltd had appealed a first-instance ruling in favour of the Australian Manufacturing Workers’ Union (AMWU). The Full Bench granted permission to appeal (an appeal of this kind can proceed only with the Commission’s permission) and then dismissed the appeal in a dispute over Visy’s overtime availability process.

The dispute arose under the Visy (Smithfield, Warwick Farm, Dandenong, O’Connor) Enterprise Agreement 2022, which incorporates the Graphic Arts General Award 2000 as it stood on 1 March 2006. In January 2025 Visy introduced a process to cover unplanned leave. Employees initial a wall planner if they want to be contacted for overtime. Those marked “Available” may be rung after their shift and asked to start four hours early. Visy’s memorandum stated: “There is no call back rate to be paid as this is not a call back due to employees volunteering for overtime and agreeing to be contacted outside of their normal shift time.”

Graphic Arts General Award 2000, cl.6.5.1

Call back applies when an employee is called back to perform work at a time when they would not ordinarily be at work and the employee has not been notified prior to last finishing work that they would be so called back.

The two readings produce different pay for a four-hour block. Under Visy’s construction, the block is paid as overtime: three hours at time and a half and one hour at double time, a total of 6.5 hours’ ordinary pay. Under the AMWU’s construction, the employee receives one hour of ordinary pay for the call back plus four hours at double time, a total of 9 hours’ ordinary pay.

Visy argued

that being “called back” implies compulsion, meaning the employer must summon or require the worker to return. It relied on authorities including Polan v Goulburn Valley Health [2016] FCA 440. It argued the call back premium had no rationale where the employee volunteered, and submitted that marking oneself “available” amounted to prior notification under the second limb of clause 6.5.1.

The AMWU argued

that the entitlement can arise when an unforeseen or unplanned event leaves the employer needing work done, regardless of whether the employer directs the worker to return or asks and the worker accepts.

The Full Bench found

that where an employer needs work done and asks an employee to come back to do it, the employee is called back if they agree. “No greater degree of compulsion is required.”

The Full Bench accepted that the return must be initiated by the employer. A worker who turns up unilaterally is not called back. But it said Visy wrongly treated being required to return and volunteering as “mutually exclusive”. It drew on Telstra Corporation Ltd v Peisley; Chief Commissioner of Police v Kerley, where police self-nominated on a whiteboard; and Manildra Flour Mills v National Union of Workers.

It also described Visy’s approach as “impractical and unrealistic”, because pay would depend on dissecting each phone call to decide whether it was an order or a request the worker could have refused. On the premium, it found that the interruption to an employee’s time off is just as sudden whether or not they volunteered.

The notification argument also failed. The Full Bench held that what must be notified is a firm decision to recall the worker on a specific occasion. Knowing a call is possible is not enough. “If knowledge of a possibility of being called back were sufficient, clause 6.5.1 could rarely be triggered. That cannot be correct.”

At a glance

  • Parties: Visy Board Pty Ltd v Australian Manufacturing Workers’ Union
  • Citation: [2026] FWCFB 269, appeal from [2026] FWC 2455
  • Bench: Vice President Gibian, Deputy President Easton, Deputy President Grayson
  • Section: Fair Work Act 2009, s.604; Graphic Arts General Award 2000, cl.6.5
  • Outcome: Permission to appeal granted, appeal dismissed
  • Who it affects: Employees covered by the Visy (Smithfield, Warwick Farm, Dandenong, O’Connor) Enterprise Agreement 2022

The appeal was heard in Sydney on 25 September 2026 and decided on 13 October 2026.

In granting permission to appeal, the Full Bench noted that the call back provision is replicated in substantially the same terms in clause 29 of the Graphic Arts, Printing and Publishing Award 2020, so the construction “has importance beyond the present case”.

Source: [2026] FWCFB 269

General information only. OnNotice reports developments in Australian industrial relations, human resources and workplace law. This article is for education purposes only and is not intended to form professional advice. Always confirm against the primary source and seek specific advice relating to your circumstances.

Share this storyLinkedInWhatsAppTeamsFacebookX

Keep reading