Court security and custodial officers employed by Ventia Australia in Western Australia will not be moved onto G4S rates. A Full Bench of the Fair Work Commission has declined to award the pay parity sought by the Transport Workers’ Union, which said in its application for an intractable bargaining declaration that the parties had been negotiating for 18 months, that it had taken seven separate instances of protected action, and that employees had twice voted down Ventia’s version of the agreement.
At a glance
- Parties: Transport Workers’ Union of Australia, Western Australian Branch v Ventia Australia Pty Ltd (B2025/1425)
- Citation: [2026] FWCFB 258, Perth, 30 September 2026 (Deputy President O’Keeffe, Commissioner Schneider, Commissioner Lim)
- Sections: Fair Work Act 2009 ss.234, 269, 270A, 272, 273, 274, 275
- Outcome: intractable bargaining workplace determination made; pay parity with G4S refused; nominal expiry date of 30 June 2028
- Who it affects: Ventia employees performing court security and custodial services under the company’s contract with the Justice Department of Western Australia
A 28.94% gap at the most common grade
The union put a table of comparative rates before the Full Bench, setting the rates that applied under the 2022 Agreement from 1 November 2022 against G4S rates as at 1 July 2025. A Ventia CS & CSO was on $30.93 an hour against $39.88 for the equivalent G4S classification, and a Ventia controller on $36.74 against $47.22. The Full Bench noted that at the most common grade, CS & CSO, the differential was 28.94%.
Under the union’s model, the November 2022 rates would have risen by 3.7% from 1 November 2023 and by 4% from 1 November 2024, before reaching parity with G4S on 1 November 2025. Tables in the decision show that final step as a 19.55% increase at CCO Level 2 and 19.17% for controllers and supervisors.
Two failed votes, both 74% against
The Ventia CS & CS & TWU Enterprise Agreement 2022 reached its expiry on 1 December 2023. Ventia agreed to bargain for a replacement on 19 February 2024, which fixed the notification time under s.173(2)(a). Ten bargaining meetings, an application by Ventia under s.240 for bargaining assistance, conferences in November and December 2024 and a series of stoppages followed. Employees rejected Ventia’s version of the agreement twice, in October 2024 and September 2025, each time with a 74% no vote.
- 1 Dec 2023 The 2022 Agreement expires.
- 19 Feb 2024 Ventia agrees to bargain, fixing the notification time.
- 9 Oct 2024 The TWU is granted a protected action ballot order.
- 10 Sep 2025 The TWU applies for an intractable bargaining declaration.
- 10 Oct 2025 The declaration is granted in [2025] FWC 3049.
- 18 to 20 Feb 2026 Three days of hearing in Perth.
- 15 Apr 2026 Final written submissions received.
- 30 Sep 2026 Determination made.
The intractable bargaining declaration (a declaration under s.234 that bargaining has reached a deadlock, which allows the Commission to set the terms itself) was made on 10 October 2025. Both parties told the Commission that a further bargaining period would serve no purpose, so no post-declaration negotiating period was specified under s.235A, and the Commission was required by s.269 to make the determination as quickly as possible.
Whether G4S was the right yardstick
that its members carry out substantially the same role as G4S officers stationed in Western Australian courts, that lower rates had driven turnover and attracted inexperienced recruits, and that parity would keep experienced officers, reducing safety incidents and abatements. It pointed to Ventia Services Group’s net profit after tax of $227.9 million for the year ended 31 December 2024 on revenue of $6.1 billion, and to the Western Australian government’s commitment of an extra $6 million to the contract. In supplementary closing submissions it argued the phrase “pay parity” is “rather synonymous with the mantra ‘same job same pay’”.
that there is “no statutory requirement or case precedent” requiring pay parity, that the work differs because its officers perform prison transfers and regional services that G4S does not, and that the union’s attrition evidence was hearsay. It said turnover had begun to decrease, to the point of a hiring freeze for the six months ended November 2025, and that it pays “in line with the broader industry”. Granting the claim, it said, would threaten “Ventia’s paper-thin margin on the CS&CS Contract”.
that nothing in the Act compels pay parity in a determination of this kind. Rates paid in the broader industry “will be a useful guide”, the Bench said, but “they are not a hard and fast target to be met”. It declined to award parity with G4S and treated the union’s reliance on same job same pay as a misplaced analogy.
The Full Bench said of that argument:
“The notion of “same job same pay” applies to workers at the same workplace working side by side doing the same job and with one employer ultimately footing the bill for all of them. It is not intended to apply across an industry such that all workers doing a particular type of work should get the same rate.”
Bargaining in the shadow of the state contract
The Justice Department contract began its initial five-year term in 2017, when it was held by Broadspectrum Australia. Ventia Services Group acquired Broadspectrum in 2020 and the business was renamed Ventia Australia Pty Ltd. After extensions, the contract runs to March 2027 and the department may extend it, at its absolute discretion, until March 2032. Only the department may terminate the contract for convenience.
The Full Bench said bargaining between the parties takes place “in the very deep shadow cast by the JDWA contract”, with revenue from that contract largely fixed. It distinguished the Cleanaway decisions relied on by the union, finding that Ventia does not appear able to lift the prices it charges its customer and certainly cannot do so unilaterally.
Two years, not three
The TWU sought a nominal expiry date of 30 June 2028, a two-year term it said would allow the parties to rebuild the relationship. Ventia sought three years, pointing to the eighteen categories of industrial action the union notified during bargaining and the defensive steps it said it took on each occasion, and arguing that the relationship needed a period of stability.
The Full Bench did not favour a three-year term. Given the role played by the Justice Department, it preferred bargaining to occur once the contract parameters were set, allowing bargaining in an environment of greater certainty “which in turn may reduce the likelihood of future industrial action”. It adopted the union’s 30 June 2028 expiry date, noting there is no barrier to the parties starting negotiations before the determination expires.
The agreed dispute clause was replaced
On the definitions of full-time and part-time employment, the Full Bench retained the status quo from the 2022 Agreement: a full-time employee works a minimum of 76 hours per fortnight and a part-time employee less than 76 hours per fortnight. The union had sought a set 38-hour week. The Bench found the current provision superior to the Corrections and Detention (Private Sector) Award 2020 and to at least some other agreements in the industry, and that the union’s concerns about hypothetical problems under the hours clause were misplaced.
The parties had agreed a dispute resolution clause, but the Full Bench found that it limited when an employee could be represented and so did not satisfy s.186(6)(b). The model dispute resolution clause in Schedule 6.1 of the Fair Work Regulations 2009 was inserted in its place. The agreed flexibility and consultation terms were retained.
On delegates’ rights, the agreed Union Delegate Training clause gave five days paid training leave on election or appointment with no further entitlement, while clause 26A of the award provides up to five days initial training and one day each subsequent year. The Full Bench inserted clause 26A as a term of the determination and, although s.273(7) does not reference s.205A, took the view that the inserted clause should nonetheless be regarded as rendering the agreed training clause of no effect.
Source: [2026] FWCFB 258
General information only. OnNotice reports developments in Australian industrial relations, human resources and workplace law. This article is for education purposes only and is not intended to form professional advice. Always confirm against the primary source and seek specific advice relating to your circumstances.