An application filed inside the 21 day deadline named a different individual as the applicant and gave incorrect details for the respondent. The person named as applicant had no obvious connection to the worker who had instructed the paid agent.
Commissioner Matheson extended time for the general protections application (a claim that a dismissal contravened the workplace rights and discrimination protections in Part 3-1 of the Fair Work Act 2009) to 2 April 2026, the date the corrected form was filed. The decision, [2026] FWC 3880, issued on 9 October 2026 following a determinative conference on 8 October 2026.
At a glance
- Parties: A dismissed worker and Greater West Landscapes Pty Ltd
- Citation: [2026] FWC 3880 (Commissioner Matheson)
- Section: s.365 and s.366(2) of the Fair Work Act 2009
- Outcome: Extension of time granted; application taken as made on 2 April 2026
- Who it affects: Applicants who rely on paid agents to lodge general protections applications
The dismissal took effect on 6 March 2026 and the 21 day period under s.366(1)(a) ended on 27 March 2026. The worker contacted Unfair Dismissal Experts Pty Ltd on 12 March 2026, telling it he had been dismissed, and was assured the claim would be filed within time. The paid agent lodged on 20 March 2026 with incorrect details for both parties, although the rest of the information in the application was correct.
An employee of the paid agent gave evidence that its system is built to fill contact and identifying details into forms automatically, and that a technical fault occurred when two separate clients who shared a surname became confused with one another. The worker also goes by a longer version of his name that includes that surname. The mistake was picked up in a routine audit on 2 April 2026 and a corrected Form F8 was sent to the Commission that day. Commission staff advised that the original application could not be amended because both the applicant and respondent details needed to change, and that the new form would be treated as a fresh application. The application was therefore filed six days late.
- 6 Mar 2026 Dismissal takes effect.
- 12 Mar 2026 Worker instructs the paid agent, which says the claim will be lodged in time.
- 20 Mar 2026 Application lodged with incorrect applicant and respondent details.
- 27 Mar 2026 21 day period under s.366(1)(a) ends.
- 2 Apr 2026 Error found in a routine audit; corrected Form F8 filed and treated as a new application.
- 9 Oct 2026 Extension of time granted.
Permission for the worker to be represented by the paid agent was granted under s.596(2)(a). The Commissioner took into account that the extension application relied on representative error, that she would be hearing directly from the paid agent about that error, and that representation would allow the matter to be dealt with more efficiently given its complexity.
that representative error requires primary consideration of the applicant’s own behaviour, and that the Commission could not assess it because the worker filed no evidence himself. It said there was no evidence he reviewed or approved the form, that “even a rudimentary review of the documents would have identified the errors”, and that both he and the paid agent had a further seven days after the incorrect lodgement in which to act. A “routine audit”, it submitted, was insufficient to establish exceptional circumstances.
that the paid agent had identified “completely different parties that were unconnected to the Applicant”, so it was not appropriate to allow a correction under s.586(a). The delay was caused by the paid agent’s error, and “it was reasonable for the Applicant to assume that the Paid Agent had lodged his application on time as per its commitment to do so”. The reason for the delay and the worker’s action in contacting the paid agent to dispute the dismissal both weighed in favour of exceptional circumstances.
On the merits, the worker said he was told he did not align with the employer’s culture. He alleged a contravention of s.351, on the basis that adverse action was taken because of a disability, after discussions about his health at work about two weeks before the dismissal. The employer’s construction manager gave evidence that the worker started on 3 November 2025 on a six month probationary period, that staff raised concerns within the first few weeks, that a 10 week probation review rated him “Low” in certain behavioural areas and “Low” on whether he was likely to pass probation, and that the dismissal followed further complaints about a failure to follow directions and conduct toward others. The employer denied any disability was a factor in the decision.
The Commissioner described her impressionistic view of the merits as not strong, being unable to attach significant weight to “bald assertion and the very limited particulars expressed in the application”, and treated that as weighing marginally against an extension. She noted the parties had not been directed to file evidence on their substantive case, and that findings would ultimately be made by a court after hearing the evidence. Prejudice to the employer and fairness as between the worker and others in a like position were both neutral considerations.
The Commission will list the matter for a conference, at which mediation or conciliation will be attempted. On the question of correcting the original form, the Commissioner accepted that there are occasions when the discretion in s.586(a) may properly be exercised to fix an error in an application, but held that it was not appropriate here because the form filed on 20 March 2026 identified parties unconnected to the worker.
Source: [2026] FWC 3880
General information only. OnNotice reports developments in Australian industrial relations, human resources and workplace law. This article is for education purposes only and is not intended to form professional advice. Always confirm against the primary source and seek specific advice relating to your circumstances.