A worker told by text message that she was no longer welcome at her workplace has won her unfair dismissal application uncontested, after her employer failed to file a response for more than a year despite repeated contact from the Fair Work Commission.
Deputy President Butler found the dismissal harsh, unjust and unreasonable and granted the application in a decision issued on 9 October 2026, decided on the papers at Brisbane. The respondent is The Trustee For CDM Family Trust, trading as Dan’s Truck Detailing.
The worker began with the business on 4 October 2022 and was dismissed with immediate effect on 5 September 2025. She filed her application on 14 September 2025, within the period required by s.394(2) of the Fair Work Act 2009.
On the uncontested facts, the worker was not rostered at the business on 4 September 2025 and was working at a second part-time job the employer knew about. The business operator contacted her by phone and text about the whereabouts of another employee. She could not reply immediately, and received an aggressive and abusive message in response. A screenshot was filed with the application. On her account, a further message the next day carried threats and degrading remarks, levelled personal accusations and suggested the sender knew her whereabouts and who she was with. The same message told her she was no longer welcome at the workplace.
Deputy President Butler found the 5 September message made clear she was dismissed, and that the dismissal took effect that day. The decision records that no reason related to conduct or performance was given, that the worker had never been counselled or warned, and that she was given no opportunity to respond.
- 14 Sep 2025 Unfair dismissal application filed.
- 25 and 29 Sep 2025 Registry attempts to phone the respondent, without success.
- 1 Oct 2025 Application posted to the respondent; delivery could not later be confirmed.
- 24 Oct 2025 The respondent’s contact person tells the Registry he will file a form F3 response. He does not.
- 19 Jan 2026 Mention and directions hearing. The applicant appears, the respondent does not.
- 22 Jan 2026 Chambers sends the application and a blank response form by express post. Australia Post tracking confirms arrival. No response.
- 29 May 2026 Directions issued giving the respondent until 15 June 2026 to respond.
- 9 Oct 2026 Application granted.
Deputy President Butler found the application had been served and the respondent was aware of it, and that the application and the facts asserted in it were therefore uncontested. With no facts in dispute, the matter could be determined without a conference or hearing.
Working through s.387, the Deputy President found there was no valid reason for dismissal related to capacity or conduct, so the considerations in s.387(a), (b) and (c) did not arise. The employer was accepted as a small business employer, and the dismissal was found to be clearly inconsistent with the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code and not a genuine redundancy. On the size of the enterprise under s.387(f), the decision states that the consideration carried little weight.
“this consideration is of little weight given small businesses are generally able to avoid dismissing employees in such an unreasonable manner” Deputy President Butler
The same reasoning was applied to the likely absence of dedicated human resource expertise under s.387(g). Under s.387(h), the Deputy President identified the absence of any valid reason, the capricious character of the dismissal, the “vile and abusive language used”, the lack of procedural fairness and the fact that the dismissal took effect immediately as weighing strongly in favour of a finding of unfairness.
At a glance
- Parties: A former employee v The Trustee For CDM Family Trust, trading as Dan’s Truck Detailing
- Citation: [2026] FWC 3865, Deputy President Butler
- Section: Fair Work Act 2009, ss.385, 387, 390 and 394
- Outcome: Dismissal found harsh, unjust and unreasonable; application granted uncontested
- Who it affects: Small business employers, including those that do not respond to a Commission application
Remedy remains open. Section 390(3) bars an order for compensation unless the Commission is satisfied that reinstatement would not be appropriate and that compensation is warranted in all the circumstances of the case. The parties had not been directed to file material on remedy, and Deputy President Butler said a further directions order will be issued separately to allow them to be heard on reinstatement and compensation.
Source: [2026] FWC 3865
General information only. OnNotice reports developments in Australian industrial relations, human resources and workplace law. This article is for education purposes only and is not intended to form professional advice. Always confirm against the primary source and seek specific advice relating to your circumstances.