A production operator at the Mount Pleasant coal mine in the Hunter Valley will return to work at Thiess Pty Ltd, even though the Fair Work Commission found he twice raised his fist at a colleague and threatened to knock him out. Deputy President Saunders held that Thiess had a valid reason to dismiss him, but that summary dismissal (termination without notice) was harsh.
The operator worked at the mine for Thiess from 13 March 2022 until he was summarily dismissed on 16 April 2026. He also had earlier labour-hire service at the site. The dismissal followed a confrontation with another operator on 20 March 2026 that began as a dispute over a work sequence on the two-way radio.
The threat was proved
Thiess relied on three allegations put during its investigation: argumentative radio exchanges, aggressive and offensive language on the ground, and raising a fist at the colleague twice. The radio recordings were played several times during the hearing. The Deputy President found that each man was argumentative and disrespectful towards the other, though at “a low level of seriousness”.
The accounts of the face-to-face exchange differed. The operator accepted he threatened to knock the colleague out, but said he pointed with his left hand from a raised windrow after the colleague called him a slur. The colleague said the operator raised his fist and he stepped back. The Deputy President preferred the evidence of a supervisor who was present, describing him as the most reliable witness with “no motive to lie”, and found the fist was raised twice. He rejected the supervisor’s evidence that the operator may have shoulder-charged the colleague, finding no contact occurred.
The Deputy President applied the Briginshaw standard, which requires stronger proof the more serious the allegation. He concluded the conduct gave Thiess a “sound, defensible and well-founded” reason for dismissal.
The Deputy President said: “It is inappropriate for an employee to threaten another employee at work.”
Arguments that failed on both sides
Thiess raised a fourth allegation in oral submissions only: that the operator misled its investigation. It was never put to him or included in the termination letter. The Deputy President rejected it, finding both men gave honest accounts and that differing recollections of “a brief interaction” did not establish dishonesty.
The operator argued he had no meaningful opportunity to respond because Thiess did not give him all its evidence or explain why it rejected his responses, that the outcome was prejudged because the termination letter was drafted before the final meeting, and that Thiess did not call the decision-maker. Each argument was rejected. His claim of inconsistent treatment, because the colleague received only a written warning, also failed: the Deputy President found the operator was the aggressor and the only one who made a threat, so the comparison was not “apples with apples”.
Why the dismissal was still harsh
Under s.387(h) of the Fair Work Act 2009, the Deputy President weighed the operator’s record, which was exemplary apart from a written warning on 15 September 2025 over a dozer tipping incident. He accepted confidential evidence about the operator’s personal circumstances and a medical condition, finding he was triggered when the slur was directed at him aggressively. There was no physical contact or attempt at assault, the operator kept working safely for the rest of the shift, and he apologised to the supervisor that afternoon.
The Deputy President said Thiess “cannot turn a blind eye to threatening or aggressive behaviour” at an open cut coal mine, but described the conduct as an isolated incident: “If there had been any such prior incident, the outcome of this case would have been very different”. The operator was unable to find work between 16 April and 25 August 2026, fell behind on mortgage repayments, and now works casually on a drive-in, drive-out roster away from the Hunter Valley.
that reinstatement was inappropriate because the conduct struck at the trust and confidence the relationship needs, the operator kept disputing the findings, and he raised the trigger explanation only after he was dismissed.
was that he apologised to the supervisor before leaving the site on the day of the incident, admitted making the threat in his written statement of 22 March 2026, and had re-engaged in psychological treatment.
that the operator had never denied threatening the colleague, that he told the supervisor on the day what had triggered him, that standing by his own recollection did not show a lack of insight, and that the supervisor had no concerns about his return. The colleague said at the hearing he would not want to work with the operator again, but the Deputy President was confident that with leadership and supervision they could work cooperatively.
Reinstated, but no back pay
The Deputy President ordered reinstatement under s.391 and continuity of employment under s.391(2)(a). He declined to order lost pay under s.391(3), which at most would have been about $60,000 gross, saying that not making the order “will serve to remind” the operator “not to act in a similar manner at work in the future”.
The decision, [2026] FWC 4087, was issued on 21 October 2026 after a hearing in Newcastle on 14 and 15 October. A separate order, PR815636, gives effect to it. It applies the Full Bench principle that a dismissal can be harsh despite a valid reason, here where a threat was proved but found isolated, triggered by a slur and not accompanied by any attempt at violence.
At a glance
- Parties: A production operator v Thiess Pty Ltd
- Citation: [2026] FWC 4087, Deputy President Saunders
- Section: Fair Work Act 2009, ss.387, 391, 394
- Outcome: Valid reason found, dismissal harsh, reinstatement and continuity ordered, no lost pay
- Who it affects: Thiess and the operator at the Mount Pleasant mine
Source: [2026] FWC 4087
General information only. OnNotice reports developments in Australian industrial relations, human resources and workplace law. This article is for education purposes only and is not intended to form professional advice. Always confirm against the primary source and seek specific advice relating to your circumstances.