Southern Cross Care cannot move Victorian aged care staff onto its Queensland agreements despite claimed 77% staff support

Southern Cross Care has failed in a bid to move staff at its Oasis aged care facility in Victoria onto its Queensland enterprise agreements. The Fair Work Commission found the workers would lose leave, allowances and, for some, consultation rights, and that key differences were not explained to them before they were surveyed.

6 min read
Fair Work Commission
Share this storyLinkedInWhatsAppTeamsFacebookX

Staff at the Oasis aged care facility in Victoria will stay on their existing enterprise agreement after Southern Cross Care (Qld) Ltd failed to have them moved onto its Queensland agreements. The provider told the Fair Work Commission that 77% of Oasis employees supported the switch. Deputy President Lake dismissed the application on 19 October 2026 in Southern Cross Care [2026] FWC 4067, finding the employees would be disadvantaged and that the change would cut across bargaining that had already begun.

Southern Cross Care bought the Oasis facility in 2024. Its employees were covered by the Southern Cross Care Broken Hill Limited and ANMF Oasis Staff Enterprise Agreement 2019-2023 (the Broken Hill Agreement), which applies at two sites: Oasis in Victoria and selected houses in Broken Hill. On a transfer of business, an existing enterprise agreement can follow the employees to the new owner as a “transferable instrument”. Section 318(1)(a) of the Fair Work Act 2009 allows the Commission to order that it does not.

The provider sought that order. Under its proposal, Enrolled Nurses, Registered Nurses, Clinical Nurse Specialists and Deputy Directors of Nursing would move to the Southern Cross Care Queensland and QNMU Nurses Enterprise Agreement 2024-2027. Other employees, including Assistants in Nursing and Allied Services Employees, would move to the Southern Cross Care Queensland Aged Care Enterprise Agreement 2024-2027. The Australian Nursing and Midwifery Federation (ANMF) opposed the application. The Health Workers’ Union, which is not a party to the agreements, was invited to make submissions and appeared at a hearing on 17 March 2026.

At a glance

  • Parties: Southern Cross Care (Qld) Ltd (applicant); ANMF (opposing); Health Workers’ Union (made submissions)
  • Citation: [2026] FWC 4067, Deputy President Lake, 19 October 2026
  • Section: Fair Work Act 2009, s.318(1)(a) and s.318(3)
  • Outcome: Application dismissed; the Broken Hill Agreement continues to cover the Oasis staff
  • Who it affects: Oasis aged care employees in Victoria covered by the Broken Hill Agreement

Survey support carried little weight

Southern Cross Care said it began circulating correspondence about the transition on 30 April 2025, ran staff information sessions and roadshows on 3 July 2025, and issued a voluntary survey on 23 July 2025. It met the ANMF several times before lodging the application on 17 October 2025. It told the Commission 39 of 53 employees voted in favour of moving to the Queensland agreements, with 9 supporting negotiation of a new agreement.

The Deputy President found the employees’ views “can, at most, only weigh marginally in favour of the transfer”. He said “key differences between the agreements were left out when the effect of the change was explained to employees”.

“There is significant reason to doubt that employees were given sufficient information in order to provide their views.” Deputy President Lake

An employee’s witness statement filed by the ANMF said staff “didnt know that we would be loosing the hours on these leaves untill informed by ANMF representative”. One employee who gave evidence in favour of the transfer said she would rather have the higher base rate than the leave, but conceded she had not received a clause-by-clause comparison of the two sets of agreements. Six employees emailed views to the Commission. One opposed the transfer and estimated a shift change would cost around $3000 a year in earnings.

Leave, allowances and a consultation carve-out

Southern Cross Care argued

that no employee would be worse off, as base rates and most allowances met or exceeded the Broken Hill Agreement. It accepted that personal leave, parental leave and the in-charge, sleepover, leadership and qualification allowances were less favourable. It said the Queensland agreements provide “modern, consistent and equitable terms and conditions” across its sites, and offered to keep paid parental leave and partner leave for a 12 month transitional period and to consider take-home pay protection for up to 12 months.

The ANMF argued

that the claim no employee would be worse off was false. It identified entitlements missing from the Queensland agreements, including a structured disciplinary procedure, accident pay, weekend penalties of 150% on Saturday and 175% on Sunday, change of roster and on-call allowances, and blood donors and community services leave. It said the employer had not provided material in writing, had not provided materials to culturally and linguistically diverse employees in their own language, and that the survey should be given minimal weight.

The Deputy President found

that while base pay rates may be higher, several conditions in the Queensland agreements “would place the employees at a disadvantage, which weighs against the transfer”.

He singled out personal leave. The Broken Hill Agreement provides 21 days a year after five years of service, against 10 days a year under the Queensland agreements. The Broken Hill Agreement pays a shift allowance of $24.81 for Personal Care Workers and $27.03 for Registered Nurses for each morning or afternoon shift. The Queensland agreements have no morning shift allowance.

He also pointed to the Queensland consultation clause, which states that “[t]he requirement to consult under this clause does not apply where an Employee has irregular, sporadic or unpredictable hours”. He said this “may effectively exclude casual employees from consultation” and that, to the extent it is enforceable at all in the face of s.205 of the Act, it is disadvantageous to a cohort of employees.

A bargaining round already under way

The Broken Hill Agreement passed its nominal expiry date on 1 November 2023. Both Queensland agreements nominally expire on 31 August 2027. The ANMF said it had begun bargaining for a new agreement in 2024, before the purchase, and that the Queensland dates would “neuter” the employees’ ability to bargain for a Victorian-specific agreement. The employer said no employee had “expressed a desire to commence bargaining”.

The Deputy President found any replacement agreement would be delayed until after August 2027 and that, with bargaining already begun in 2024, “the transfer would operate unfairly”. On the public interest, he cited the object in s.3(f) of the Act of “achieving productivity and fairness through an emphasis on enterprise-level collective bargaining”, noting the business “was purchased knowing there was an enterprise agreement in place which had passed its nominal expiry date”. He also said the Broken Hill Agreement’s term letting disputing parties choose the Commission member would encourage “Member-shopping”, but found the public interest did not favour the orders.

Efficiency arguments carried little weight

Southern Cross Care argued that running dual payroll and parallel rostering was “inefficient” and “resource intensive” in a sector that “operates on tight funding”. The Deputy President found productivity neutral, saying “the productivity which may be achieved by having employees under centralised agreements is likely to be short-lived” because different state laws and conditions apply. On economic disadvantage, he said the Act requires “significant economic disadvantage”, the submissions were too general to establish it, and the employer knew or ought to have known the likely cost when it bought the business. He found that factor neutral.

One factor favoured the provider. The Deputy President found a low degree of business synergy between the agreements, noting different classification definitions for registered and enrolled nurses, and said this weighed in favour of the transfer. He distinguished an earlier decision the employer relied on, Estia Investments Pty Ltd T/A Estia Health, as made without union opposition or employee submissions.

Weighing the s.318(3) considerations, the Deputy President gave more weight to employee disadvantage and the public interest and dismissed the application. The Broken Hill Agreement therefore continues to cover the Oasis employees in Victoria, and bargaining for its replacement is not displaced by Queensland agreements running to 31 August 2027.

Source: [2026] FWC 4067

General information only. OnNotice reports developments in Australian industrial relations, human resources and workplace law. This article is for education purposes only and is not intended to form professional advice. Always confirm against the primary source and seek specific advice relating to your circumstances.

Share this storyLinkedInWhatsAppTeamsFacebookX

Keep reading