Industrial Court orders police prosecutor to pay $3,000 costs, not the $15,985.85 sought, over failed appeal on respondents’ legal representation

A Queensland police prosecutor who lost an appeal over how his employer’s side was legally represented has been ordered to pay $3,000 of the respondents’ costs. The Industrial Court of Queensland found the appeal was brought without reasonable cause, and fixed costs at $3,000 against the $15,985.85 the State and three individual respondents had sought.

4 min read
Industrial Court of Queensland
Share this storyLinkedInWhatsAppTeamsFacebookX

A Queensland police prosecutor has been ordered to pay $3,000 towards the costs of an appeal he lost, well short of the $15,985.85 the respondents had asked for. The Industrial Court of Queensland found the appeal was instituted without reasonable cause. It accepted the prosecutor had genuine concerns about collusion, noted the respondents did not suggest the appeal was vexatious, and set the costs at a fraction of the amount claimed.

The worker was employed as a prosecutor with the Brisbane Police Prosecution Corps from May 2019. The court said his relationship with the State, his employer, broke down for a range of reasons. On 28 May 2024 he filed a claim in the Queensland Industrial Relations Commission under s 285 of the Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld). The claim seeks compensation from the State and three individuals he says took adverse action against him because he exercised his workplace rights.

The respondents applied under s 530(1) of the Act for leave to be represented by private counsel. The worker opposed the application. The Commission granted leave on 7 July 2025. The worker appealed, and the Industrial Court dismissed the appeal on 2 October 2026. The collusion and public-money objections failed on appeal.

His main ground, added by amendment, was that the Commission failed to consider “collusion and misuse of public resources” when deciding whether to require that the three individual respondents not be represented by Crown Law.

No party asked to make oral submissions, so costs were determined on the papers. Davis J, President, delivered the decision on 2 November 2026.

In civil litigation the general rule is that the losing party pays the winner’s costs. Queensland’s industrial jurisdiction starts from the opposite position. Each party bears its own costs unless a limited exception applies.

Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld), s 545(1)

(1) A person must bear the person’s own costs in relation to a proceeding before the court or commission.

Under s 545(2)(a), the court or commission may, on a party’s application, order another party to pay costs if satisfied that party made or responded to the application “vexatiously or without reasonable cause”, or that “it would have been reasonably apparent to the party that the application or response to the application had no reasonable prospect of success”.

The respondents submitted

that the appeal lacked reasonable cause or, alternatively, that the worker should reasonably have seen it had no reasonable prospects of success. They sought fixed costs of $15,985.85, which was two-thirds of their actual costs of $24,221. In the alternative, they sought costs on the Supreme and District Court scale under Schedule 1 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999.

The worker submitted

that the appeal had reasonable cause and was not hopeless. He said the parties had engaged in real argument. He relied on paragraph [23] of the court’s reasons on appeal: “There was no consideration in the judgment of the allegations of collusion or the use of public money to fund private respondents.” He challenged the $15,985.85 figure and argued that any costs should be assessed on the scale.

The Court found

that the worker was right that the Commission had not considered those arguments. However, “neither of those points were ever going to win the day” either in the Commission or on appeal. It held the appeal was “clearly” instituted without reasonable cause under s 545(2)(a)(i). It did not decide whether the second limb, no reasonable prospect of success, was also met.

On collusion, the court said the worker had made serious allegations, “including implications against lawyers employed by the Crown Solicitor”, and that there was “no basis that I can see to support such serious allegations.” On public money, the court said the State decides how its money is spent and “the state government is answerable to the democratic process.”

The court treated the $15,985.85 claimed as effectively an estimate of the respondents’ full party/party costs. It found the worker “should bear some of the costs”. It noted he had genuine concerns about collusion and that the respondents did not suggest the appeal was vexatious. It fixed costs at $3,000 rather than sending them for assessment on the scale.

At a glance

  • Parties: A police prosecutor (appellant) v State of Queensland (Queensland Police Service) and three individual respondents
  • Citation: [2026] ICQ 023, Davis J, President, 2 November 2026
  • Section: Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld), s 545(2)(a)(i); Industrial Relations (Tribunal) Rules 2011 (Qld), r 70
  • Outcome: Appellant to pay the respondents’ costs of the appeal, fixed at $3,000
  • Who it affects: Parties to proceedings in the Queensland industrial jurisdiction, where each side ordinarily bears its own costs

The costs order concerns only the appeal over legal representation, not the merits of the adverse action claim. With the appeal dismissed, the Commission’s grant of leave for the respondents to be represented by private counsel stands.

Source: [2026] ICQ 23

General information only. OnNotice reports developments in Australian industrial relations, human resources and workplace law. This article is for education purposes only and is not intended to form professional advice. Always confirm against the primary source and seek specific advice relating to your circumstances.

Share this storyLinkedInWhatsAppTeamsFacebookX

Keep reading