A part-time finance and administration worker has lost her unfair dismissal claim. On the managing director’s own account, he had told her that her job would “more than likely” go, and he gave her a payout estimate before any formal consultation. The Fair Work Commission found her dismissal by Advanced Mobile IT Pty Ltd (AMIT) was a genuine redundancy within the meaning of s.389 of the Fair Work Act 2009.
A finding of genuine redundancy is a complete answer to an unfair dismissal application. Under s.396 the Commission must decide that question first, and if the redundancy is genuine the merits of the claim are never reached.
AMIT supplies and installs in-vehicle mobile computing equipment and employed around 34 people. The worker started in February 2015 as full-time Office Manager. Her hours were reduced by agreement in 2024. She was dismissed on 26 March 2026 and sought compensation.
A conversation before the letter
On 12 March 2026, AMIT’s managing director spoke to her about selling the business. Their accounts of that conversation differed. She said he told her the sale would lead to redundancies, including in finance, because the new owners would bring in their own finance team, and that her redundancy package would be around $50,000. He said he told her a restructure was being considered, partly because of a possible sale, and that her position was “more than likely” to be made redundant. He also said he gave her an estimate when she asked what she would be paid, while noting final figures had not been worked out. Deputy President Slevin found the difference did not matter. On either version, the managing director was giving her early, informal warning of a process that might affect her job.
A formal letter followed on 17 March 2026, handed over by the company’s human resources and compliance manager. It said the company was looking at automating or outsourcing its accounts payable work, or merging it into another organisation’s finance function. It said nothing had yet been finalised and asked for feedback by 23 March 2026. The worker emailed on 22 March asking for written confirmation of whether she was being made redundant, and met the HR manager on 24 March. Later that day she met the managing director. She said he told her the decision had been made and consultation was “just a formality”. He denied saying that. Two days later she was handed a termination letter giving four weeks’ notice. Her last day was 23 April 2026.
that her position was not redundant, that the decision had been made by 12 March so consultation was merely a formality, and that AMIT failed to take reasonable steps to find her another role.
that the dismissal was a genuine redundancy, relying on the 17 March letter as its consultation, and that it was not harsh, unjust or unreasonable in any event.
that all three limbs of s.389 were met. On consultation he found the worker “did not engage in discussions about the decision but repeatedly asserted that a final decision had been made”, and that “Her belief that the termination of her employment was inevitable resulted in a failure to take up the opportunity in consultation.”
How each limb was met
On whether the job was still needed, documents showed that financial software had taken over most of her tasks and the remainder had been shifted to colleagues. She did not dispute that evidence in substance, but objected that she had not seen the task breakdown until the matter reached the Commission.
On consultation, the obligation came from clause 38 of the Clerks Private Sector Award, and the Deputy President found it had been complied with. He distinguished Orientile Pty Ltd v Carson Q Zhang [2026] FWCFB 162, where an employee was called in without warning and told his job was redundant. Here the worker was forewarned, given a letter, invited to respond and met the company.
On redeployment (moving the employee into other work rather than dismissing them), he applied the five elements set out by the High Court in Helensburgh Coal Pty Ltd v Bartley [2025] HCA 29.
A person’s dismissal was not a case of genuine redundancy if it would have been reasonable in all the circumstances for the person to be redeployed within: (a) the employer’s enterprise; or (b) the enterprise of an associated entity of the employer.
The only role identified for possible redeployment was a Project Coordinator position in Melbourne, and the Deputy President found no suitable position was vacant or available for her. AMIT’s one associated entity employed a single person. He found that given the size of the business “there was little scope to rearrange or reorganise the workforce to facilitate redeployment”. He also found that her skills centred on financial accounts, most of which were being automated, and that although she had once been a finance manager, someone else held that role at the time of the dismissal.
At a glance
- Parties: A former finance and administration employee v Advanced Mobile IT Pty Ltd
- Citation: [2026] FWC 4047, Deputy President Slevin, 19 October 2026
- Section: Fair Work Act 2009, ss.385, 389, 394, 396; Clerks Private Sector Award clause 38
- Outcome: Dismissal a genuine redundancy; application dismissed
- Who it affects: Small employers restructuring through automation, and employees in consultation over proposed redundancies
The matter was heard in person on 22 September 2026. The worker represented herself and the managing director appeared for AMIT. The decision applies the High Court’s Helensburgh Coal test to a small employer with almost no internal positions to absorb a displaced worker. OnNotice has also reported on other redundancies found genuine under s.389. The decision also records that the employee’s refusal to engage, on the belief the outcome was already settled, weighed against her consultation complaint.
The refusal is the rule, not the exception. OnNotice examined every late unfair dismissal claim finally decided in published decisions this year: 3 of 38 won a further period, a grant rate of 7.9 percent, and two of the three were one day late.
Source: [2026] FWC 4047
General information only. OnNotice reports developments in Australian industrial relations, human resources and workplace law. This article is for education purposes only and is not intended to form professional advice. Always confirm against the primary source and seek specific advice relating to your circumstances.