Staff who moved to Opal HealthCare when it took over the Clendon Care aged care facility in Lidcombe, NSW, will be covered by Opal’s own enterprise agreement, not the agreement they worked under at Clendon Care. Deputy President Cross granted the application under s.318 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) in a decision dated 14 October 2026.
The transfer of business took effect on 1 October 2026, when DPG Services Pty Ltd, trading as Opal HealthCare, took over running the facility from Clendon Care Pty Ltd. Opal offered employment to 95 Clendon Care employees, and 67 had confirmed acceptance to start on 1 October 2026. Their work, which covers nursing, personal care, therapy and support services, is substantially unchanged.
Without an order, the Clendon Care, NSWNMA & HSU East Branch Enterprise Agreement 2012 would have followed the employees to Opal as a transferable instrument (an industrial instrument that moves with employees to a new employer after a transfer of business under s.318). Opal sought orders that the Clendon Care agreement would not cover the transferring employees and that the Opal HealthCare (NSW) Enterprise Agreement 2023 would.
Opal told the Commission that 60 of 95 transferring employees would receive a higher rate of pay under the Opal Agreement. For 34 employees, the equivalent Opal classification carries an identical hourly rate. One employee was paid a higher base rate under the Clendon Care agreement, and Opal said that rate would be preserved. Opal also said employees’ service would remain continuous for all purposes, and that their accrued personal, annual and long service leave, along with their service with Clendon Care, would be recognised.
Opal argued its agreement offered superior wages, penalty rates and classification progression, uncapped annual leave that attracts leave loading, better paid family and domestic violence leave, improved paid parental leave and higher allowances. It also pointed to conditions absent from the Clendon Care agreement, including nurse handover time and police check renewal fees.
Opal also acknowledged that seven Clendon Care terms were more beneficial: a job search entitlement, regrading of classifications, an overtime meal allowance for aged care employees, weekly overtime triggers for part-time and for casual employees, cashing out of annual leave, and leave without pay. It submitted these were conditional entitlements arising only “in specific and discrete circumstances”, that their loss would have “a negligible impact”, and that the Opal package was more beneficial on balance.
The NSWNMA did not oppose the application, in a submission dated 25 September 2026. The HSU told the Commission by email on 29 September 2026: “The HSU does not oppose the application.” No transferring employee lodged a formal objection.
On disadvantage under s.318(3)(b), Deputy President Cross found no employee would be worse off on base pay and that the overall impact was “neutral to positive”. He adopted the approach of Deputy President Colman in DPG Services Pty Ltd [2022] FWC 1651, which assesses disadvantage overall.
“In my view this consideration is concerned with the question of whether any employees would be disadvantaged on an overall, rather than a line-by-line basis.” Deputy President Colman, adopted in [2026] FWC 3932
The Deputy President noted the Clendon Care agreement passed its nominal expiry date (the date after which an agreement can be replaced, though it continues to apply) on 30 June 2015, and the Opal agreement on 30 June 2026. He found that operating two agreements at the one facility would reduce administrative efficiency and add costs, including manual payroll processing. He found limited alignment between the instruments: the Opal agreement applies across multiple NSW facilities, while the Clendon Care agreement would cover only the Lidcombe site. He said the order supported “employment certainty, consistent care standards, and broader public interest goals in the aged care sector”.
The matter was determined on the papers (decided on written material without a hearing). The decision applies the overall, rather than line-by-line, test to an order that removes conceded better terms where the replacement agreement is more beneficial on balance and the unions do not object. The order is to be issued separately.
At a glance
- Parties: DPG Services Pty Ltd trading as Opal HealthCare (applicant); NSWNMA and HSU (did not oppose)
- Citation: [2026] FWC 3932, Deputy President Cross, 14 October 2026
- Section: Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), s.318
- Outcome: Order granted. Clendon Care agreement does not cover transferring employees; Opal HealthCare (NSW) Enterprise Agreement 2023 applies
- Who it affects: Employees transferring from Clendon Care to Opal HealthCare at the Lidcombe aged care facility from 1 October 2026
Source: [2026] FWC 3932
General information only. OnNotice reports developments in Australian industrial relations, human resources and workplace law. This article is for education purposes only and is not intended to form professional advice. Always confirm against the primary source and seek specific advice relating to your circumstances.