The Fair Work Commission has decided to grant the CEPU a single interest employer authorisation covering three air conditioning and mechanical services contractors operating in South Australia. The final wording of the order is still to be settled. A single interest employer authorisation is an order that lets bargaining proceed for one enterprise agreement across several employers. Where a bargaining representative applies, employers can be brought into it without their consent if the statutory requirements are met. Two of the three businesses opposed the order.
The employers are O’Connors Mechanical Construction (SA) Pty Ltd, Watson Fitzgerald and Associates Pty Ltd and D&E Air Conditioning Pty Ltd. O’Connors and D&E Air opposed the application. Watson Fitzgerald did not seek to be heard and said it would accept the outcome. Deputy President Hampton decided the matter under ss.248 and 249 of the Fair Work Act 2009 in [2026] FWC 2649, handed down in Adelaide on 22 October 2026 after a hearing on 13 and 14 July 2026.
At a glance
- Parties: CEPU v O’Connors Mechanical Construction (SA) Pty Ltd, Watson Fitzgerald and Associates Pty Ltd, D&E Air Conditioning Pty Ltd
- Citation: [2026] FWC 2649
- Section: Fair Work Act 2009, ss.248, 249 and 250
- Outcome: Authorisation to issue for all three employers. Final terms still to be settled.
- Who it affects: As identified in submissions, employees of the three employers who work in South Australia in air conditioning, refrigeration and plumbing, excluding project managers and administrative staff
A petition the Commission called less than ideal
Because the union applied and the employers did not consent, the CEPU had to show that a majority of the covered employees at each employer wanted to bargain for the agreement (s.249(1B)(d)). It relied on an online petition run through Formbricks.
The Commission compared the names on the petition with the employers’ staff lists. A preliminary report issued on 16 March 2026 found majorities at two employers: 22 of 28 covered employees at Watson Fitzgerald, and 22 of 42 at O’Connors. At D&E Air, only 12 of 27 had signed.
The CEPU then ran a supplementary petition at D&E Air. A further preliminary report on 16 April 2026 found that 22 of 28 employees on D&E Air’s February list had signed, and 21 of 26 on its April list.
The petition’s closing statement asked signatories to confirm that they wanted “to bargain with my employer for an enterprise agreement”, including as part of a multi-employer agreement. The Deputy President said the final question “was less than ideal”. Read in isolation, it could be taken as endorsing enterprise bargaining generally. Taken as a whole, however, he found it “tolerably clear” that the petition sought support for a multi-employer agreement in the industry that “would cover Plumbers, Refrigeration Mechanics, and Duct Erectors”. He noted this was clearly stated in the petition’s welcome statement.
Union organiser Adrian Valente gave evidence that the CEPU held meetings with members at each employer in May and June 2025, emailed members on 3 October 2025, and held a mass meeting of about 100 members at the Fitzroy Community Club on 16 October 2025. The 3 October email explained that, for the Commission application, the union had to show that a majority of workers at each company “want to bargain for a multi-employer agreement.”
that employees were asked only whether they wanted an enterprise agreement, not specifically a multi-employer one. It said the union had not told employees that the proposed coverage was the coverage for which authorisation would be sought, and that not everyone who signed received any further explanation. On that basis, it said, the Commission could not rationally reach the required state of satisfaction.
that the process after the first report lacked transparency. It said its employees had no fair chance to revisit or confirm their earlier responses, and that new signatures were simply combined with the original petition.
that CEPU members who signed would reasonably understand a multi-employer agreement was proposed. He was satisfied on the balance of probabilities that “the great majority” of signatories had received the necessary information. On D&E Air, he said: “In some circumstances, I would have significant reservations about relying on what was in reality a cumulative petition”. Given the almost unchanged workforce and the margin of support, he found the result “both valid and reliable for present purposes”.
Mr Valente said D&E Air members who had already signed and still agreed could “keep it as is”. Employees could withdraw support, but only outside the petition process. The Deputy President described that withdrawal process as “admittedly less than ideal”. He found a majority at each employer as at 6 February 2026, the date the Commission fixed for the assessment. The evidence put the total across the three businesses at 98 relevant employees as at that date, of whom 66 had completed the petition.
Attending meetings was not agreeing to bargain
O’Connors also relied on s.249(1D)(b). That provision excludes an employer from an authorisation if the employer and the union have “agreed in writing to bargain for a proposed single-enterprise agreement” covering substantially the same employees.
O’Connors issued a Notice of Employee Representational Rights on 5 August 2025, seeking to make a single-enterprise agreement. The CEPU replied on 7 August 2025: “Whilst we do not agree to bargain for a single enterprise agreement, we are prepared to participate, in good faith, as a bargaining representative in that process.” The union attended a bargaining meeting on 5 November 2025 and later meetings, and lodged its application on 16 December 2025.
O’Connors argued that the CEPU had committed in writing to participate in good faith, supplied its own proposed terms and asked for those terms to be balloted. The union had also said it would not campaign for a “no” vote. The CEPU said it did not agree in writing, “or for that matter in any way, shape or form”, and that O’Connors’ account was a rationalisation constructed after the event.
The Deputy President found no written agreement. He said the CEPU attended meetings “as it was obliged to” under the good faith bargaining requirements of s.228, “whilst retaining its position” that it sought a multi-employer agreement. He found the union’s offer of an alternative draft for the ballot was conditional and did not amount to an agreement either. O’Connors put its own single-enterprise agreement to a vote on 23 April 2026, and it did not receive majority support.
Family business, national player, same template
All three employers had 50 or more employees when the application was made. That triggered rebuttable presumptions that they had clearly identifiable common interests, that the authorisation was not contrary to the public interest, and that their operations and business activities were reasonably comparable. A rebuttable presumption means the requirement is taken to be met unless the contrary is proved.
Managing director Andrew O’Connor gave evidence that O’Connors is a family business with a long engineering history, particularly in defence work. The company contended it was “genuinely South Australian based”. D&E Air submitted that it is a large national business whose South Australian operations are comparatively small, and that it competes with Tier 1 mechanical contractors.
The Deputy President generally accepted the factual basis of Mr O’Connor’s evidence but found it partly self-serving. He said there did not appear to be “any meaningful connection” between those business differences and different bargaining interests. He noted that the three employers frequently work for the same clients, are covered by the same modern award, and have occasionally shared staff on large projects. Their three existing agreements with the CEPU were “strikingly similar”.
The Deputy President said: “There are marginal differences on wages, but they appear to have been based upon the same template”. He added that the objecting employers had treated those agreements as meeting their interests, which tended to show their underlying bargaining interests were relevantly common.
He found that the presumptions had not been overcome and that nothing had been identified that might “genuinely challenge the public interest”.
A defence that expired with the timetable
O’Connors had also asked to be excluded under s.250(3) because it was already bargaining. That ground applies only where less than nine months have passed since the most recent nominal expiry date of the employer’s agreement. All three agreements nominally expired on 31 October 2025. The Deputy President said the ground applied at the time of the hearing. However, “due to the agreed (and lengthy) timetable” and the time needed to decide the matter, “that circumstance does not now apply”.
- 5 Aug 2025 O’Connors issues its Notice of Employee Representational Rights.
- 7 Aug 2025 CEPU says it does not agree to bargain for a single enterprise agreement.
- 31 Oct 2025 All three existing agreements reach their nominal expiry date.
- 16 Dec 2025 CEPU lodges its application.
- 16 Mar 2026 Preliminary report finds no majority at D&E Air.
- 16 Apr 2026 Further report shows a majority after the supplementary petition.
- 23 Apr 2026 O’Connors’ single-enterprise agreement fails at a ballot of employees.
- 22 Oct 2026 Commission decides the authorisation will issue.
The wording of the order is still open
The CEPU’s draft order describes employee coverage in broader terms than the petition and the union’s own submissions. The Deputy President observed that it partly reflects the union’s constitutional coverage. He found that the agreement the CEPU is pursuing is relevantly the same one employees supported in the petition. O’Connors had asked to be heard further on how the employee group should be specified. The CEPU has 7 days to file and serve a draft authorisation that takes account of the decision. The employers then have a further 7 days to make submissions in response.
Under s.249(4), an authorisation comes into operation on the day it is made. It ceases when the agreement is made or 12 months later, unless that period is extended.
Source: [2026] FWC 2649
General information only. OnNotice reports developments in Australian industrial relations, human resources and workplace law. This article is for education purposes only and is not intended to form professional advice. Always confirm against the primary source and seek specific advice relating to your circumstances.