Nutrien denied indemnity costs after ex-manager drops claim challenging a separation deed he says he signed under a 20-minute deadline

Nutrien AG Solutions has failed to recover its legal costs from a former National Procurement Manager who withdrew his general protections claim. The Commission found the claim was not manifestly untenable, and that rejecting a no-costs settlement offer was not unreasonable.

5 min read
Fair Work Commission
Share this storyLinkedInWhatsAppTeamsFacebookX

Nutrien AG Solutions wanted its former National Procurement Manager, Agchem & Seed, to pay its legal costs on an indemnity basis after he discontinued his general protections claim before it reached a hearing. His claim alleged he had been dismissed in contravention of the general protections provisions of the Fair Work Act. Deputy President Beaumont dismissed the costs application.

The worker had been employed since 6 September 2010. In around October 2025 Nutrien began investigating misconduct allegations, which the Deputy President said were “of a serious nature”. On 13 October 2025 he agreed to resign and signed a Separation and Release Agreement. On 21 November 2025 the terms were varied after Nutrien gathered further material, some of it from his mobile phone, which it said showed he had not been honest about one allegation. Nutrien said the original terms had depended on him being honest with it about the investigation.

Two accounts of one meeting

Nutrien submitted that when confronted, the worker “openly admitted to committing multiple instances of serious misconduct” and was given a choice between resigning on agreed terms and facing disciplinary action. It said he elected to resign.

The worker’s account came through a letter his lawyers, MKI Legal, sent to Nutrien on 11 June 2026. It said he was given “a strict twenty-minute ultimatum to execute the October Deed”, was not allowed to pause the meeting, step out or get his own legal advice, and was “deliberately refused permission to read” a second document identified as a letter of summary termination. He maintained he did not sign either agreement voluntarily.

He filed his claim under s 365 on 11 June 2026. Nutrien objected that he had not been dismissed and that the signed agreements barred the claim. On 22 June 2026 its lawyers, Lander & Rogers, warned him of a possible costs application and made a Calderbank offer (a settlement offer that can later be relied on when costs are argued): discontinue, with each side bearing its own costs. The offer expired on 26 June 2026.

Chambers twice reminded the parties of the Commission’s costs powers and of decisions holding that the Commission cannot set aside a settlement agreement said to have been signed under coercion or duress. On 10 August 2026 Chambers told the worker his submissions lacked cogency and directed him to say whether he would discontinue or seek an adjournment. He discontinued the same day. Nutrien applied for costs on 24 August 2026, and the matter was decided on the papers (on written material, without a hearing).

Fair Work Act 2009, s 375B(1)

The FWC may make an order for costs against a party (the first party) to a dispute for costs incurred by the other party to the dispute if: (a) an application for the FWC to deal with the dispute has been made under section 365; and (b) the FWC is satisfied that the first party caused those costs to be incurred because of an unreasonable act or omission of the first party in connection with the conduct or continuation of the dispute.

Nutrien argued

that the worker caused its costs through unreasonable acts or omissions under s 375B. In the alternative, it argued under s 611(2) that the claim was made vexatiously and without reasonable cause, or that he should reasonably have seen it had no reasonable prospect of success. It took issue with his refusal of the no-costs offer.

The worker argued

that he was self-represented. He said neither question raised (whether he was dismissed, and whether the agreements were binding and operative) was frivolous, given Nutrien itself ran two objections. He also said he acted on the 10 August 2026 direction within an hour. He said Nutrien’s two offers required a full release of all employment claims when he could not yet quantify possible underpayments.

Deputy President Beaumont found

that whether he was dismissed was “contentious” and would have required factual findings, so neither Nutrien’s objection nor the claim was “manifestly untenable or groundless”. Rejecting the offer “did not constitute an unreasonable omission or act”, because the claim “was at an early stage, the factual context was contentious and there were several principles of law at play.”

The Deputy President said the worker had misunderstood what the Commission could do. However, it was still open to him to seek an adjournment while pursuing the agreements in a court, as his own 20 July 2026 submissions had proposed. “It is well established that the Commission has no jurisdiction to determine whether a binding settlement agreement may be set aside, however, a court does,” the Deputy President said. When asked to clarify his position, “he acted promptly”.

At a glance

  • Parties: A former employee v Nutrien AG Solutions Limited
  • Citation: [2026] FWC 3926, Deputy President Beaumont, Perth, 13 October 2026
  • Section: Fair Work Act 2009 ss 375B, 611(2)(a) and (b)
  • Outcome: Costs application dismissed
  • Who it affects: Employers seeking costs after a general protections claim is discontinued

The decision applies Full Bench authority in Qantas Airways Ltd v Carter that whether an application was vexatious, without reasonable cause or had no reasonable prospect of success under s 611 is judged at the time it was made. It also notes the legislative intention, set out in the Supplementary Explanatory Memorandum and described by the Full Bench in Keep v Performance Automobiles as consistent with the other costs provisions, that s 375B be used only where there is clear evidence of unreasonable conduct. Whether the separation agreements could be set aside was never decided. The decision notes that question is for a court, not the Commission.

Source: [2026] FWC 3926

General information only. OnNotice reports developments in Australian industrial relations, human resources and workplace law. This article is for education purposes only and is not intended to form professional advice. Always confirm against the primary source and seek specific advice relating to your circumstances.

Share this storyLinkedInWhatsAppTeamsFacebookX

Keep reading