A fly-in fly-out loader operator who refused to keep working alongside a colleague, flew out of a Nullagine gold site halfway through his rostered swing and wrote on a timesheet that the position “will now be ending for me” was still dismissed at his employer’s initiative, the Fair Work Commission has found.
The worker was engaged on a casual basis on or around 30 March 2026 by Mining Employment Services, a labour hire partnership trading through four trustee companies, as a run-of-mine loader operator on the Nullagine Gold Project. The assignment agreement named AIM Mining Corporation Limited as the client and gave the estimated duration of the assignment as “TBA”. AIM told the Commission that it is the parent company of Millenium Minerals Pty Ltd, and that Millenium operates the project, holds the labour hire contract and pays the provider’s invoices. Deputy President Beaumont recognised Millenium as third respondent, AIM remained as second respondent, and the first respondent’s name was amended to add its four trustee companies: Amakon Pty Ltd, Forrest Consultancy Services Pty Ltd, Sheringham and Co Pty Ltd and Eastern Districts Metallurgy Pty Ltd.
An incident involving a colleague occurred on the run-of-mine pad on 29 May 2026. The worker did not attend work the following morning, citing fatigue, and told the client’s process coordinator that he would not continue on the same crew as the colleague and pressed for a move to another crew. He was told there were no vacancies on the other crew. He was stood down on pay while the complaint was investigated. At a meeting at 3.00pm on 31 May 2026 he was told the complaint had been investigated, that his allegations were not borne out by the evidence, and that the company would agree to his request to go home. He flew out on 1 June 2026, halfway through a swing that was rostered to run until 8 June 2026.
On 31 May 2026 he lodged a timesheet recording 89 hours and six zero-hour days, with a note that was sent to the client for approval.
I will be flying out tomorrow 01/06/2026, and will not be doing night shift, this position will now be ending for me, I’m devastated because they have tried to cover up a serious incident and expected me to comply with that process but I have refused to do that.
He called a recruitment consultant at the labour hire provider on 8 June 2026 asking when he would return to site. On 9 June 2026 he was told the client did not want him back. The provider’s general manager asked whether he wanted to be considered for further assignments and he said he did. Since then the provider has not placed him on another assignment or raised one with him.
The respondents raised a jurisdictional objection (an argument that the Commission has no power to deal with the application) on the basis that there had been no dismissal. Entitlement to bring an application under s 365 of the Fair Work Act 2009 for the Commission to deal with a general protections dismissal dispute depends on the person having been dismissed, and where that is in issue the Commission must decide the question before it can conduct a conference under s 368. The definition in s 386(1) has two limbs: termination on the employer’s initiative, and a resignation forced by the employer’s conduct. The Commission treats that definition as applying in s 365 matters in the same way as in unfair dismissal cases, including where a resignation is said to have been a dismissal.
that no causative act occurred on their part. The worker “had already withdrawn the services he had been assigned to provide and thereby brought the assignment to an end”, by repeatedly refusing to perform the rostered work and by leaving site before his rostered period of work was complete. The labour had been sought to fill a vacant position on A Crew, so that roster pattern was material to the assignment, and the refusal to work with the colleague “went to the heart of why his services had been supplied”.
that none of its conduct had ended the employment relationship or was likely to have that effect, and that the employment ended because the worker declined to keep working on the terms set out in the assignment agreement.
that the first respondent ended his employment on 9 June 2026, when it told him his services were no longer required on the project, and that this was a termination at the employer’s initiative even though the direction to cancel the assignment came from the client. He relied on Star v WorkPac Pty Ltd [2018] FWC 4991, in which a casual labour hire employee was found to have been dismissed when demobilised from a mine site.
that the worker’s withdrawal of his services was repudiatory conduct, but that it did not of itself end the assignment. “What brought the Applicant’s assignment to an end was the Second Respondent’s election to not accept the Applicant’s repudiatory conduct and thereafter inform the First Respondent that it no longer required the Applicant on its Project.” The first respondent then communicated to the worker on 9 June 2026 that the assignment had ended. The employment ended at the initiative of the first respondent.
On the principles, the decision records that a repudiatory breach does not bring a contract to an end by itself but gives the innocent party a right to elect to terminate, and that for the purposes of s 386(1), “it is only once the employer makes the election to accept the repudiation that the dismissal occurs”. Star was distinguished. The employee in that case had spent more than four years at a single site on a regular roster and had not withdrawn her services before being demobilised.
The Deputy President preferred the evidence of the client’s process coordinator over that of the applicant, noting the coordinator “was forthright with his answers and was not affected by the level of frustration and anger experienced by the Applicant” between 29 and 31 May 2026.
At a glance
- Parties: A former casual loader operator v Mining Employment Services (four trustee companies), AIM Mining Corporation Limited and Millenium Minerals Pty Ltd
- Citation: [2026] FWC 3677, Deputy President Beaumont, Perth, 24 September 2026
- Sections: Fair Work Act 2009 ss 365, 368, 370 and 386(1)
- Outcome: Jurisdictional objection dismissed; the worker found dismissed at the first respondent’s initiative on 9 June 2026; matter listed for conference
- Who it affects: Labour hire providers, mining and resources host clients, and casual employees engaged on client assignments
The matter will now be listed for a conference. If the dispute is not resolved, the Commission may issue a certificate under s 368(3)(a), after which a general protections court application must be made within 14 days of the certificate being issued, or within such period as the court allows. The decision also records the Full Court’s observation in Coles Supply Chain Pty Ltd v Milford that a Commission finding on entitlement to apply may not be conclusive, and that a court may decline to recognise the application or the resulting certificate if a respondent objects to the competency of a court application under s 370.
Source: [2026] FWC 3677
General information only. OnNotice reports developments in Australian industrial relations, human resources and workplace law. This article is for education purposes only and is not intended to form professional advice. Always confirm against the primary source and seek specific advice relating to your circumstances.