NSW Department of Education teacher’s resignation ruled a constructive dismissal after principal refused her release to a non-school role

A teacher who resigned from the NSW Department of Education was in fact dismissed, the state’s Industrial Relations Commission has found. Deputy President Howell found the department failed to release her into a two-year non-school role it had offered her, and failed in its duty to provide suitable employment. Whether the dismissal was unfair is…

7 min read
NSW Industrial Relations Commission
Share this storyLinkedInWhatsAppTeamsFacebookX

A teacher who resigned from the NSW Department of Education in January 2026 was dismissed, the NSW Industrial Relations Commission has found. The department’s conduct, not her resignation, was “the real and effective initiator” of the end of her employment.

Deputy President Howell found the department failed to release the teacher into a two-year non-school based role that it had itself offered her. At the time, she was facing a possible medical retirement. He also found the department failed to comply with s 49 of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 (NSW) (the WIM Act). That section requires an employer to provide suitable employment to an injured worker on request.

The decision, [2026] NSWIRComm 1106, was handed down on 29 October 2026. It settles only the threshold question of whether there was a dismissal. Whether the dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable, and what remedy may follow, will be decided at a further hearing.

At a glance

  • Parties: A former permanent classroom teacher and the Secretary, Department of Education
  • Citation: [2026] NSWIRComm 1106
  • Decision maker: Deputy President Howell
  • Legislation: Industrial Relations Act 1996 (NSW), Part 6 of Chapter 2; WIM Act, s 49; Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW), s 32A
  • Outcome: Resignation found to be a dismissal; unfairness and remedy to be heard later
  • Scope: A threshold ruling on the facts of one teacher’s case against the department

A role the department offered, then did not release her into

The teacher began working for the department in January 2017 and held a permanent classroom teaching position at a public high school. In March 2022 she suffered a physical workplace injury. In her words, that injury “subsequently resulted in a psychological injury”. Both injuries were accepted as compensable under workers compensation legislation.

From 5 June 2023 she held a temporary three-year non-school based teaching role as a curriculum adviser. She kept a right of return, which is an entitlement to go back to her substantive position when a temporary appointment ends. The role was cut short by a departmental restructure announced on 2 September 2024, and she was not placed in the new structure.

By early 2025 her treating doctor was certifying her as fit for full-time work, but not in a school setting. On 20 March 2025 the department offered her “suitable duties” in her classroom role at her school. The Deputy President said that, in light of her medical certificates, “it obviously was not” suitable employment. On 2 October 2025 the department issued a notice of intent to consider medical retirement under s 76 of the Teaching Service Act 1980 (NSW).

Return-to-work staff had told her to find alternative roles through ordinary merit selection, and she kept applying for non-school based positions. On 2 December 2025 she was unsuccessful in one application. She was, however, placed on an eligibility list, a pool of suitable candidates who can be offered later vacancies without a full selection process. On 16 January 2026 the department activated that list and offered her a temporary role from 27 January 2026 to 30 January 2028. The offer was conditional on her principal approving her release and her right of return.

The principal refused to release her on 23 January 2026, citing staffing and school operations for 2026. The teacher had not worked at the school since 2022 and remained certified unfit for classroom work. She resigned on 30 January 2026, and her employment ended on 6 March 2026. She filed an unfair dismissal application under Part 6 of Chapter 2 of the Industrial Relations Act 1996 (NSW) on 25 March 2026. She represented herself.

What each side argued

The teacher argued

that the department’s course of conduct left her with no reasonable or effective choice but to resign. She said the department refused to release her to the role, closed off the escalation pathway its own policy provided, and gave her confusing advice suggesting that resigning would let her take the position. She also argued the department breached s 49 of the WIM Act by failing to provide suitable employment.

The department argued

that she resigned voluntarily. It said she did not re-engage with the medical retirement process or reschedule a cancelled medical case conference. It also said she was never told to resign, was advised against relinquishing her position, and “had multiple genuine options available to her”.

Deputy President Howell found

that “There may well have been options, but to characterise them as ‘genuine options’, which in context can only mean genuine options to continue her employment, appears an overstatement.” He found her failure to re-engage with the medical retirement process did not bear in any material way on who initiated the termination.

Why a resignation became a dismissal

The Deputy President applied the test in Allison v Bega Valley Council (1995) 63 IR 68. Under that test, the question is whether, despite an apparent resignation, it was the employer’s conduct that in reality brought the employment to an end. He noted that constructive dismissal (where an apparent resignation is, in law, a termination by the employer) is not confined to cases where an employee faces the choice to “jump or be pushed”.

He identified three features of the department’s conduct. First, it failed to release her into the role while medical retirement was pending. Second, it advised her to escalate the principal’s decision to a director, a course he described as “doomed to fail”, and he also relied on the advice that director gave her when she did. Third, it failed to decide promptly on her offer to relinquish her right of return. He found nothing in the evidence showing the offer had been passed to anyone in the department able to decide it.

Continuing to deny the Applicant the opportunity to take up the e-list NSBT position conditionally offered to her was, in my view, thoroughly unreasonable.

He also accepted that, during a call to the department’s EdConnect service on 27 January 2026, she was told resigning was an option for securing the role, while also being told EdConnect did not recommend that course. He found that “erroneous advice contributed” to her decision. His conclusion was that the department “did not force her to resign”, but its conduct “unduly influenced the employee to resign”.

He rejected her reliance on an earlier aged care decision in which an employment relationship was described as an “empty husk”. He found that the department “did not cover itself in glory” in providing suitable employment. However, it had continued to communicate with her, and there was no suggestion it had stopped accruing her leave.

The suitable employment duty rests with the department, not the school

The Deputy President held that the offered role was “suitable employment” as defined in s 32A of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW). He based this on her medical certificates, her qualifications, her 18 months in a comparable role and the department’s own assessment of her as suitable. She had requested that work. Section 49 required the department to provide it.

Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 (NSW), s 49(1)

(1) If a worker who has been totally or partially incapacitated for work as a result of an injury is able to return to work (whether on a full-time or part-time basis and whether or not to his or her previous employment), the employer liable to pay compensation to the worker under this Act in respect of the injury must at the request of the worker provide suitable employment for the worker.

s 49(2)

(2) The employment that the employer must provide is employment that is both suitable employment (as defined in section 32A of the 1987 Act) and (subject to that qualification) so far as reasonably practicable the same as, or equivalent to, the employment in which the worker was at the time of the injury.

The department’s policy required the principal’s approval for the release. The Deputy President said: “I do not accept it was not reasonably practicable to provide that suitable employment simply because of a policy restriction self-imposed by the Respondent”. He found the obligation was borne by the department, not by the principal or the school.

He found that none of the return-to-work coordinators who managed her matter “ever gave any real consideration” to a non-school based placement as part of a recovery at work plan, despite the terms of the department’s own policy. He noted that binding resolution of suitable employment disputes lies with the Personal Injury Commission. The Industrial Relations Commission may still decide such questions when exercising its own functions, which here meant determining an unfair dismissal application.

Next listed for 2 November

The matter is listed for directions at 9.30am on Monday 2 November 2026, by audio-visual link. The purpose is to program a final hearing on whether the dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable and, if so, what relief may be appropriate. The department was represented by counsel instructed by Clayton Utz. The teacher represented herself.

Source: [2026] NSWIRComm 1106

General information only. OnNotice reports developments in Australian industrial relations, human resources and workplace law. This article is for education purposes only and is not intended to form professional advice. Always confirm against the primary source and seek specific advice relating to your circumstances.

Share this storyLinkedInWhatsAppTeamsFacebookX

Keep reading