A section supervisor at the Cleveland Youth Detention Centre who faces a proposed dismissal has had two of six disciplinary findings against him set aside. The Queensland Industrial Relations Commission held that part of the conclusion on one allegation was not open on the footage, and that the reasons on another did not weigh the direction under which the supervisor had acted.
The appeal was brought under s 131 of the Public Sector Act 2022 (Qld) as a fair treatment decision, that is, a decision the employee believes to be unfair and unreasonable. It was decided on the papers by Industrial Commissioner Knight. Final submissions and materials were filed on 17 July 2026 and the decision was delivered on 18 September 2026.
At a glance
- Parties: A section supervisor at the Cleveland Youth Detention Centre v State of Queensland (Department of Youth Justice and Victim Support)
- Citation: [2026] QIRC 300, delivered 18 September 2026
- Sections: s 91(1)(b) and s 91(1)(h) Public Sector Act 2022 (Qld); s 562C Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld)
- Outcome: Findings on four allegations confirmed. Findings on two allegations set aside, with other findings substituted
- Who it affects: Queensland public sector employees and decision-makers in disciplinary processes under the Public Sector Act
Six allegations, three incidents
Three of the allegations arose from a Code Yellow in the Ibis unit on 15 January 2022: unauthorised force on one young person after that young person spat blood at staff, swearing at the same young person while he was held on the ground, and the misuse of a restraint technique on a second young person.
A fourth concerned the withholding of meals from young people in the Lorikeet unit on 5 April 2022. The final two concerned 31 May 2023, when the supervisor struck an office cabinet after being punched by a young person, and did not activate his body worn camera during the preceding incident.
Two further allegations related to conduct that was the subject of criminal charges. At the request of the Australian Workers’ Union of Employees, Queensland, they were set aside until the charges had been dealt with. The Queensland Police Service later dismissed them and no findings were made on them.
A first show cause notice issued on 25 March 2024 confined the process to the remaining six allegations. On 14 February 2025 a Senior Executive Director substantiated all six, found three amounted to misconduct, found three involved a contravention of the Code of Conduct for the Queensland Public Service sufficiently serious to warrant disciplinary action, and proposed termination of employment. The appeal was filed on 3 March 2025.
(1) A public sector employee’s chief executive may discipline the employee if the chief executive is reasonably satisfied the employee has – … (b) been guilty of misconduct; or … (h) contravened, without reasonable excuse, a relevant standard of conduct in a way that is sufficiently serious to warrant disciplinary action. … (5) In this section – misconduct means – (a) inappropriate or improper conduct in an official capacity
What each side put
that the findings “lack intelligent justification”, because the decision-maker did not properly engage with his explanations, ignored that his mandatory Protective Actions Continuum training had lapsed in October 2018, and pursued discipline where management action would have been the appropriate course. On the use of force, his show cause response admitted that “my response was fueled by anger and frustration at being spat on”.
that the material before the decision-maker supported each finding and that its process met the requirements of the Public Sector Act. It acknowledged that part of the supervisor’s physical intervention training was out of date, but said that did not reduce the gravity of his departure from the Youth Justice Regulation and departmental policy, particularly in the case of a long-standing employee.
that the findings on the swearing, the restraint technique, the damage to the cabinet and the body worn camera were fair and reasonable and confirmed them. The use of force finding was fair and reasonable only in part, and the misconduct characterisation of the withheld meals was not open.
The footage did not show a bodyweight drop
The first show cause notice put the case that the supervisor had let his bodyweight fall onto the young person, his knees landing on the back of the neck and head. Having viewed the body worn camera and CCTV footage produced under an order of the Commission dated 16 June 2026, Commissioner Knight was not satisfied that conclusion was open to the required standard. What the footage showed was the supervisor moving quickly from standing to kneeling over the young person’s head, with his knee touching the side of the head as he came down, a fleeting contact incidental to that movement.
The second part of the conduct was admitted. The supervisor accepted that he then placed both hands on the young person’s neck and pushed down, while the young person lay face down on a concrete floor and was already restrained by other staff. Commissioner Knight found that “pressing down on the neck of a restrained young person went beyond what was reasonably necessary to prevent spitting”, and that misconduct was open on that conduct alone. The finding was set aside and a finding confined to the admitted conduct substituted under s 562C(1)(b) of the Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld).
Seven hours without food, on a direction from above
An incident report recorded that the three young people appeared to have received no food or water between 7.30am and 3.05pm. Each had been directed to submit to a partially clothed search before breakfast, on the instruction of a shift supervisor who told the section supervisor that “doors were not getting opened until YP complied”. Each of the three was rated “Extreme” on the Special Interest Young Person register and the searches were directed for staff safety.
Commissioner Knight held the conduct was serious: “Making access to meals conditional on compliance with a search is a form of behaviour management by deprivation of food, which is clearly what the policy bars.” The question under s 91(1)(b) was different. Following the Industrial Court’s reasoning in State of Queensland (Queensland Health) v Nield [2025] ICQ 021, misconduct requires something more than a breach of duty on its own.
The supervisor was acting on a direction from his line manager, in a custodial setting where following directions carries particular weight, and several hours into the shift he returned to that manager with a proposal that would allow the young people to be fed. Commissioner Knight found that the decision-maker had noted the direction but appeared not to weigh what it meant for how the conduct should be characterised, and had instead found misconduct on the footing that food was withheld to manage behaviour, which was the very characterisation the direction called into question.
The direction did not amount to a reasonable excuse. A finding was substituted that a ground for discipline exists under s 91(1)(h), in that the supervisor contravened cl 1.5 of the Code of Conduct without reasonable excuse in a way sufficiently serious to warrant disciplinary action, a ground the first show cause notice had raised in the alternative.
Lapsed training did not excuse the language or the improvised hold
It was not in dispute that the Department had failed to provide the annual Protective Actions Continuum training its own policy required for more than three years before the January 2022 incident. Commissioner Knight described that as a failing on the Department’s part, but found it had limited bearing on the language allegation, because the obligation to treat a child in custody with respect is stated in the Charter of Youth Justice Principles, the Code of Conduct and departmental policy rather than sourced in periodic training. On the restraint allegation, the supervisor admitted he knew staff were not permitted to improvise or alter an approved technique. The Commissioner noted the prohibition “is not a physical skill that fades without practice”.
On the cabinet, the Commissioner accepted the supervisor had just been assaulted and was, on his own account, in a state of acute stress, but found the footage captured repeated blows rather than a single blow struck in shock. “The assault was over,” the decision records. “What followed was not a defensive reaction to a threat. It was a loss of control.”
- 15 Jan 2022 Code Yellow in the Ibis unit. Three allegations arise.
- 5 Apr 2022 Meals withheld from three young people in the Lorikeet unit.
- 31 May 2023 Supervisor assaulted by a young person, strikes an office cabinet, body worn camera not activated.
- 25 Mar 2024 First show cause notice issued on six allegations.
- 14 Feb 2025 All six substantiated, termination proposed.
- 3 Mar 2025 Appeal filed.
- 18 Sep 2026 Decision delivered.
Names of the young people suppressed
The Department applied for orders suppressing the names of the young people and restricting a search of the Commission’s file, relying on s 288 and s 301 of the Youth Justice Act 1992 (Qld) and ss 25 and 26 of the Human Rights Act 2019 (Qld). The supervisor consented. Commissioner Knight noted that consent is relevant but does not decide the application, citing the Commission’s observation in Patterson that “the bar for an exception to open justice is not cleared merely because the parties do not oppose it”, and found the restriction proportionate because the names were not material to anything to be decided. Publication of identifying information is prohibited, and the material filed and produced, including CCTV and body worn camera footage, is withheld from release or search until the names and identifying details are redacted.
No decision on disciplinary action has been made. Commissioner Knight recorded that the supervisor’s eight years of service without disciplinary action, the lapse in his training, the circumstances of each incident, his admissions and his apologies would all bear on that decision, and that it remains open to him to raise those matters with the decision-maker. The decision applies Nield to disciplinary findings in a custodial setting and indicates that a characterisation of conduct as misconduct which does not engage with the direction under which the conduct occurred may not survive review.
Source: [2026] QIRC 300
General information only. OnNotice reports developments in Australian industrial relations, human resources and workplace law. This article is for education purposes only and is not intended to form professional advice. Always confirm against the primary source and seek specific advice relating to your circumstances.