Late unfair dismissal claim against Kirinari allowed after a law firm holding the worker’s $7,500 in trust missed the deadline

A worker’s unfair dismissal claim against Kirinari, filed 21 days late, will proceed because his lawyers caused the delay. The firm’s first filing had blamed the worker’s financial hardship. A second solicitor at the firm later called that account “incorrect”.

5 min read
Fair Work Commission
Share this storyLinkedInWhatsAppTeamsFacebookX

A worker who paid $7,500 into his lawyers’ trust account well inside the 21-day limit has been given more time to bring an unfair dismissal claim against Kirinari Community Services Ltd and LiveBetter Services Limited. The firm, KPW Lawyers, filed the application 21 days after the deadline had passed.

Deputy President Easton found that “all of the errors made were KPW’s errors” and that the worker was not to blame. He extended the time to make the application to 15 July 2026 under s.394(2)(b) of the Fair Work Act 2009.

Section 394(2)(a) requires an unfair dismissal application to be made within 21 days after the dismissal takes effect. The worker’s dismissal took effect on 3 June 2026, so the deadline was 11:59pm on 24 June 2026. The application was lodged on 15 July 2026. Under s.394(3), the Commission can allow more time only if it is satisfied there are exceptional circumstances, which the decision describes as circumstances that are “out of the ordinary course, unusual, special or uncommon”.

Two explanations for one delay

The Form F2 (the Commission’s unfair dismissal application form) was prepared and signed by a KPW solicitor. It said the worker “could not obtain legal advice within the 21-day timeframe due to financial hardship” because he was supporting his wife and four children.

On 26 August 2026 the Deputy President’s chambers told the parties his preliminary view was that this was unlikely to amount to exceptional circumstances. Chambers pointed the worker to cases in which financial hardship and delay in seeking advice had not been enough, and invited him to discontinue or file submissions and evidence.

A second KPW solicitor, who appears to have inherited the file, then put forward a different explanation: the worker had sought advice and given instructions within time, and “the delay arose from his legal representation and was outside his personal control.” Because the two accounts “do not sit well together”, the Deputy President required sworn witness statements. Kirinari was given the chance to respond but filed nothing.

The worker’s statement and the second solicitor’s statement set out the following sequence.

  • 3 Jun 2026 Employment terminated.
  • 4 Jun 2026 Worker contacts KPW for urgent advice about a deed of release (a document in which an employee gives up legal claims, usually in exchange for a payment) put to him by Kirinari. No one calls back.
  • 11 Jun 2026 Initial consultation at KPW about a possible unfair dismissal claim.
  • 13 Jun 2026 Worker deposits $7,500 into KPW’s trust account.
  • 15 Jun 2026 Worker provides KPW with all documents and information needed for the application.
  • 19 Jun 2026 Worker asks for an update.
  • 23 Jun 2026 KPW tells him his matter is progressing and he will be updated once the application is filed.
  • 24 Jun 2026 Deadline passes. The matter is “still with [KPW’s] office”.
  • 15 Jul 2026 Application filed.

The second solicitor said the information in the Form F2 about the reasons for delay was “incorrect”. Her understanding from the first solicitor was that the delay came from “assessments of merit, extensive review of case law and legislation”, including whether to file a general protections claim (a claim that a dismissal was for a prohibited reason, such as exercising a workplace right) instead. She took over the file on 3 September 2026 after the first solicitor resigned from the firm.

Why the delay counted as exceptional

The decision noted that a representative’s mistake may establish exceptional circumstances, provided the applicant did nothing to contribute to the delay. The Deputy President found the worker had been told on 23 June 2026 he would be updated once the application was filed, and “was entitled to assume that his application would be filed in time”. He noted the worker did not appear to have seen a draft of the application, which “might explain why the first stated reasons for the delay” placed no fault on the solicitors. He found the reason for the delay “points strongly in favour” of exceptional circumstances.

The Deputy President said the worker “should not be disadvantaged by representative error beyond his control.”

He added that the worker “should not have to pay for the work done to date by KPW Solicitors”, and that any settlement should not be increased to leave Kirinari paying his costs.

The merits weighed the other way. The Form F2 recorded an allegation of serious misconduct, and the worker had signed a Deed of Release and Separation stating “the Employee wishes to resign from the Employment” and releasing Kirinari from claims for unfair dismissal. The Deputy President said the claim “does not appear to be strong”. The remaining s.394(3) factors were neutral, including that there was no evidence of prejudice to the employer.

Finding exceptional circumstances did not oblige the Deputy President to extend time, as he retained a discretion to refuse. With Kirinari filing nothing, he said he was not satisfied that the claim “is so weak that I should decline to grant the extension of time.”

The extension allows the claim to proceed. The decision did not determine the merits, including the effect of the signed deed of release.

At a glance

  • Parties: A former employee v Kirinari Community Services Ltd and LiveBetter Services Limited
  • Citation: [2026] FWC 4241, Deputy President Easton, Sydney, 3 November 2026
  • Section: Fair Work Act 2009, s.394(2) and (3)
  • Delay: 21 days
  • Outcome: Extension of time granted to 15 July 2026 on the basis of representative error
  • Who it affects: Applicants whose representatives miss the 21-day unfair dismissal deadline

The refusal is the rule, not the exception. OnNotice examined every late unfair dismissal claim finally decided in published decisions this year: 3 of 38 won a further period, a grant rate of 7.9 percent, and two of the three were one day late.

Source: [2026] FWC 4241

General information only. OnNotice reports developments in Australian industrial relations, human resources and workplace law. This article is for education purposes only and is not intended to form professional advice. Always confirm against the primary source and seek specific advice relating to your circumstances.

Share this storyLinkedInWhatsAppTeamsFacebookX

Keep reading