Temple priest’s unfair dismissal claim proceeds after Hindu Society of Victoria emails said it had decided to terminate him

A Hindu priest who offered to resign at a meeting was dismissed by his employer’s later emails, the Fair Work Commission has found. The Hindu Society of Victoria’s objection that he resigned was rejected and his unfair dismissal claim will proceed.

4 min read
Fair Work Commission
Share this storyLinkedInWhatsAppTeamsFacebookX

The Hindu Society of Victoria’s own emails, telling a temple priest’s representative that it had “decided to terminate your client’s services”, amounted to a dismissal. That finding defeated the society’s argument that the priest had resigned at a meeting a week earlier.

Commissioner Tran dismissed the society’s jurisdictional objection (a preliminary argument that the Commission has no power to hear the claim) in [2026] FWC 4046, issued in Melbourne on 29 October 2026. The priest’s application for an unfair dismissal remedy under s.394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 will now proceed. The decision is subject to confidentiality orders.

The society is a non-profit religious association run by a management committee. The applicant had worked for it as a Sivachariyar (Hindu priest or minister of religion) without a break from at least 7 May 2024, and had held the same position on and off since 2017. In October 2025 the society learned of serious allegations about his conduct, and he was instructed to stay away from work. Meetings followed on 31 October and 24 November 2025. The applicant’s English is limited, and the first meeting went ahead without a professional interpreter.

At the 24 November meeting, the applicant’s representative indicated on his behalf that he was resigning. The society’s own later email described it as a verbal proposal “to resign, subject to a mutual deed of release and the payment of six months’ salary”. A deed of release is an agreement in which the parties give up future legal claims against each other.

Negotiations followed by email on a “without prejudice” basis (correspondence aimed at settlement that ordinarily cannot be used as evidence). On 29 November 2025, the society wrote that its committee “has determined to terminate the employment” of the applicant. On 1 December 2025, it wrote that “having decided to terminate your client’s services, for misconduct, it cannot continue to engage in discussion for other terms to end the contract”, and that if its offer was not accepted that day he “will remain terminated as from 30 November 2025”. On 3 December 2025, it sent a resignation letter for him to sign.

On 5 December 2025, the applicant’s representative emailed a resignation backdated to 30 November, saying “he feels he has been left with no practical option but to cease in his role.” He did not sign the society’s letter. On 6 December 2025, the society accepted the resignation. Because it contained no release from further claims, the society declined to pay any gratuity and told him to leave the accommodation it provided straight away.

The society argued

that the applicant resigned during the meeting on 24 November 2025. Its three witnesses each said the resignation was accepted at the meeting, while conceding that none of them could approve the payment he sought.

The applicant argued

that no resignation occurred on 24 November 2025, and that he was instead forced to resign on 5 December 2025.

Commissioner Tran found

that there was no effective resignation on 24 November, that the society’s letter of 1 December 2025 was a dismissal at the employer’s initiative taking effect on 30 November 2025, and that the 5 December resignation would in any case have been forced.

Fair Work Act 2009, s.386(1)

(1) A person has been dismissed if: (a) the person’s employment with his or her employer has been terminated on the employer’s initiative; or (b) the person has resigned from his or her employment, but was forced to do so because of conduct, or a course of conduct, engaged in by his or her employer.

Applying the Full Bench’s objective test in Sawyer v Wards Accounting Group Pty Ltd [2025] FWCFB 167, the Commissioner found the 24 November statement was not a “heat of the moment” resignation. Rather, assessed objectively, it did not take effect as a resignation. The applicant had offered to resign only on terms that were still being negotiated, and his employment “remained on foot while the respondent considered its position.” The witness who had carriage of the matter gave evidence showing the committee was divided on whether to accept the resignation and the proposal. That witness also did not regard the resignation as effective without a written letter.

The same witness said they and the board were frustrated by the delay, and that the board and congregation wanted it “done”. That was why the termination wording was used: under pressure from the congregation, the management committee just wanted “to finish the deal.”

The Commissioner held that the paragraphs recording the society’s decision to terminate were not offers to resolve and so were not part of the without prejudice correspondence. “This clearly terminated the applicant’s employment and did so upon the employer’s initiative,” the Commissioner said. The 5 December resignation was ineffective because the applicant had already been dismissed. For completeness, the Commissioner found it would also have been a forced resignation under s.386(1)(b).

At a glance

  • Parties: A priest (applicant) v The Hindu Society of Victoria (Australia) Inc.
  • Citation: [2026] FWC 4046, Commissioner Tran, 29 October 2026
  • Section: Fair Work Act 2009, s.394 and s.386(1)
  • Outcome: Jurisdictional objection dismissed; dismissal took effect 30 November 2025
  • Who it affects: Employers negotiating exit terms after an employee offers to resign

The decision dealt only with whether the applicant was dismissed. No finding has yet been made on whether the dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable. The matter will be listed for case management.

Source: [2026] FWC 4046

General information only. OnNotice reports developments in Australian industrial relations, human resources and workplace law. This article is for education purposes only and is not intended to form professional advice. Always confirm against the primary source and seek specific advice relating to your circumstances.

Share this storyLinkedInWhatsAppTeamsFacebookX

Keep reading