A pallet of charcoal weighing about 836kg was loaded onto a truck tail lifter rated to 600kg. When the platform rose, the load fell forward onto two men steadying it. One was knocked unconscious and pinned, suffering a fractured femur.
The worker who operated the lift was sentenced on 26 October 2026 in the Hervey Bay Magistrates Court. He had breached section 32 of the Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (Qld) by failing to meet his primary health and safety duty. The proceedings involved sections 28(b) and 32 of the Act. He pleaded guilty. Magistrate McGarvie fined him $10,000 and recorded no conviction.
At a glance
- Court: Hervey Bay Magistrates Court, Magistrate McGarvie
- Industry: Wholesale trade
- Legislation: Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (Qld), ss.28(b) and 32
- Date of offence: 18 March 2025
- Sentenced: 26 October 2026
- Penalty: $10,000 fine, no conviction recorded; maximum available $150,000
- Costs: $1,500 professional and legal costs, $115.50 court costs
The incident happened on 18 March 2025. Charcoal meant for the defendant had gone to the wrong address, and he went there with a truck and a pallet jack to collect it. Each pallet held 44 bags. He used the pallet jack to move a pallet onto the tail lifter. The load was too heavy and too large for the tail lifter to be used safely.
He asked two workers from the other business to help. At his direction, they held the pallet steady as he raised the lift platform. The load became unstable and fell towards them. One man moved clear and suffered minor cuts to his left arm. The other was struck by the pallet, pinned beneath it and lost consciousness. His injuries included a broken femur and cuts to his knee and eyebrow. He underwent surgery and spent a week in hospital.
Work Health and Safety Queensland received notification on the day and began investigating. The defendant voluntarily made “frank admissions”. He had never done the job before, because the charcoal usually arrived at his own business, where it was unloaded with a forklift. He could not explain why he had not considered the job or the weight limits of the pallet jack and tail lifter.
Magistrate McGarvie said the weather at the time gave some context to his decisions, and accepted the oversight was genuine. Her Honour found it was obvious the oversized load could fall from the tail lifter, and treated the fact that it did as an aggravating feature. The court also accepted that procedures at his own workplace should have prompted him to stop and think rather than rush.
On objective seriousness, her Honour found the measures that would have reduced the risk were simple and inexpensive and, though inconvenient, “were not insurmountable”. The penalty was set to reflect general deterrence and denunciation, as a reminder to others to “stop, think, and consider the safety of other people”, according to the court report.
The fine was reduced for an early guilty plea, no criminal history, good character and community contribution, genuine remorse, and full cooperation with the investigation. The maximum fine available was $150,000. He was also ordered to pay $1,500 in professional and legal costs and $115.50 in court costs. Payment was referred to SPER.
Source: primary source
General information only. OnNotice reports developments in Australian industrial relations, human resources and workplace law. This article is for education purposes only and is not intended to form professional advice. Always confirm against the primary source and seek specific advice relating to your circumstances.