Coles casual trolley collector who asked if an exit survey was his termination letter wins extra time for general protections claim

A Coles casual in Grafton who never received his emailed termination letter has been allowed to pursue a late general protections claim. The Commission found it was unreasonable for his line manager not to tell him, when he asked, that the letter had already been sent.

4 min read
Fair Work Commission
Share this storyLinkedInWhatsAppTeamsFacebookX

A casual trolley collector and cleaner at Coles in Grafton received an exit survey email on 15 May 2026 and texted his line manager the same day: “Got an email from coles that was an exit survey. Just wondering if that was my termination letter.” The line manager had written the termination letter emailed to the worker two days earlier. On 17 May he replied that the worker would need to email the area manager about it. The area manager was on annual leave at the time.

Deputy President Wright has now granted the worker an extension of time to bring a general protections claim (a claim that an employer took adverse action, such as dismissal, against a worker for a reason the Fair Work Act prohibits) under s.365 of the Fair Work Act 2009. The application was filed on 10 June 2026. Coles said the dismissal took effect on 13 May 2026. On that date, the application was seven days outside the 21-day limit.

An automated letter the worker said he never received

The worker started with Coles on 4 July 2022. He alleged that he injured his knee at work in late 2023 or early 2024 and went onto workers’ compensation, and that after returning to normal duties in about late 2024 his hours fell sharply and he complained. He claims the cut in shifts and his dismissal were adverse action because he made the compensation claim, because he complained about his hours and pay, and because of the injury itself.

Coles denied this. It said a renewal project completed in June 2024, the closure of two Grafton stores in about December 2024 and the shift of project hours to Coffs Harbour in 2025 reduced the work available to casuals. The line manager said permanent staff are rostered first, and the worker was the only casual on his roster from September 2025. His last shift was 2 February 2026.

Coles runs an automated payroll process for casuals. After 60 days without a shift, the worker is emailed and asked to update their availability on the mycoles portal. After 90 days without an update or a shift, a further email says no more shifts will be offered. The worker received the 15 April 2026 email and replied on 24 April that he could not log into mycoles but was “keen as for shifts”. Coles said it emailed the 90-day termination letter on 13 May 2026. The worker produced screenshots of his inbox and spam folder and said he first saw the letter in Coles’ response to his application, which he received on 26 June 2026.

Coles argued

that the letter went to the worker’s usual email address from the same automated account that sent the April email. It relied on the Full Bench decision in Ayub v NSW Trains [2016] FWCFB 5500 and s.14A of the Electronic Transactions Act 1999 (Cth), under which an email is treated as received once the addressee can retrieve it at their designated address. Coles said the worker’s reference to a “termination letter” showed that by 15 May he was at least on notice that his employment may have ended, and that he could have contacted the area manager or otherwise acted within the 21 days.

The worker submitted

that he did not know Coles had decided to end his employment until he received its response. He said that if he had been terminated on 13 May, he would have expected the line manager, when replying to him on 17 May, to confirm it and provide the letter.

Deputy President Wright found

that the worker did not receive the letter on 13 May 2026, that his texts were consistent with not having seen it, and that his mention of the survey showed he was keeping an eye on his inbox. As the line manager was the letter’s author, the Deputy President said it was unclear why he could not simply have told the worker that the 13 May letter was his termination letter. The line manager’s explanation for redirecting him to the area manager was rejected as “not plausible” given the area manager was on leave.

How the s.366(2) test came out

The Deputy President observed that, on one view, the dismissal did not take effect until 26 June 2026, in which case no extension of time was needed. For completeness, the s.366(2) factors were assessed on Coles’ 13 May date. The reason for the delay, and the worker’s 17 May texts, which were treated as action to dispute the dismissal, weighed in favour. Prejudice was neutral because Coles accepted it had suffered no significant prejudice. The merits were neutral because the alleged contravention could not be decided without evidence of shift patterns and the effect of store closures. Fairness to others in a similar position was also neutral.

Time was extended to 10 June 2026. The decision, [2026] FWC 3854, was determined on the papers. The matter will be programmed for a conference so the Commission can deal with it under s.368. Whether the dismissal was adverse action for a prohibited reason remains undetermined.

At a glance

  • Parties: A casual trolley collector and cleaner v Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Ltd
  • Citation: [2026] FWC 3854, Deputy President Wright, 15 October 2026
  • Section: Fair Work Act 2009, ss.365, 366(1) and 366(2)
  • Outcome: Extension of time granted to 10 June 2026; matter to proceed to conference under s.368
  • Who it affects: Employers using automated email processes to end casual engagements

Source: [2026] FWC 3854

General information only. OnNotice reports developments in Australian industrial relations, human resources and workplace law. This article is for education purposes only and is not intended to form professional advice. Always confirm against the primary source and seek specific advice relating to your circumstances.

Share this storyLinkedInWhatsAppTeamsFacebookX

Keep reading