Certis wins flexible work dispute with a Sydney Airport screener who sought to avoid 4am starts for caring duties, despite a 38-day reply

Certis Security Australia had reasonable business grounds to refuse a Sydney Airport screener’s two requests for carer-friendly hours, the Fair Work Commission has found. Certis answered the first request 38 days after receiving it, outside the 21 days the Fair Work Act allows, but that did not decide the dispute.

5 min read
Fair Work Commission
Share this storyLinkedInWhatsAppTeamsFacebookX

A Sydney Airport aviation screening officer who cares for her school-aged children, her elderly father and her disabled brother has lost her bid to have Certis Security Australia roster her only within a limited span of hours. Deputy President Cross found Certis met the requirements of s.65A(3) of the Fair Work Act 2009 for refusing a flexible working request, even though its first response came well outside the statutory deadline.

The worker is employed part time on a 32-hour weekly roster. Certis did not dispute her caring responsibilities, which mean she needs to be free in the mornings to get her children ready for and to school and to help care for family members.

Two requests, two refusals

Under s.65 of the Act, an employee who is the parent of a child of school age or younger, or who cares for an immediate family member, may make a written request for a change in working arrangements (a flexible working arrangement). The employer must respond within 21 days.

From April 2025 the worker was rostered to start at 4.00am on five consecutive days. On 4 June 2025 she asked to start around 7am and finish by 2.30pm over seven days. Certis refused on 18 July 2025, 38 days after the request, stating there was “no current roster / available line” for those hours. On 5 December 2025, after the dispute had reached the Commission, she asked instead to work 9am to 3pm on weekdays and 8am to 2pm on weekends. Certis refused that too.

Fair Work Act 2009, s.65A(3)

(3) The employer may refuse the request only if: (a) the employer has: (i) discussed the request with the employee; and (ii) genuinely tried to reach an agreement with the employee about making changes to the employee’s working arrangements to accommodate the circumstances mentioned in subsection (1); and (b) the employer and the employee have not reached such an agreement; and (c) the employer has had regard to the consequences of the refusal for the employee; and (d) the refusal is on reasonable business grounds.

Late, but not fatal

The worker argued

that Certis engaged in “a systemic, bad faith course of conduct” to exclude her from work and evade its flexible working obligations, that its response gave only “vague operational business requirements”, and that it could plainly accommodate her because it employed over 900 similar staff, spared train commuters the earliest shifts and had granted flexible arrangements to 28 other employees.

Certis argued

that the question was narrow. It accepted its first response did not strictly comply with the 21-day requirement, but said the request “changed materially over time”. It said its case was “not that no flexibility is possible” but that flexibility “must be operationally compatible with peak coverage, roster lines and team-based screening requirements”.

The Deputy President found

that Certis discussed the requests, genuinely tried to reach agreement, had regard to the consequences of refusal and refused on reasonable business grounds. He noted that after the matter reached the Commission, Certis proposed two roster lines as close as possible to the hours first requested.

Applying Duong v DHL Supply Chain (Australia) Pty Ltd [2026] FWC 2799, the Deputy President held that dealings between the parties before a formal request can show whether an employer genuinely tried to accommodate an employee’s circumstances. He found the worker’s rostering, attendance and flexibility had been “a constant issue between the parties” since at least March 2025, when she received a first written warning over absences.

Why the peaks decided it

Certis’s evidence came largely from its general manager of industrial relations. The Deputy President accepted that evidence and found it “was not seriously challenged”. Screening demand peaks early in the morning and again from late afternoon into the evening. Most of Certis’s shifts start between 3.45am and 5am, and officers work in teams of about 11, on fixed six-month rosters set to Sydney Airport’s passenger forecasts.

A 9am to 3pm shift would miss both peaks. No such roster line exists, and Certis said any extra staffing would not be funded by Sydney Airport. Its evidence was that taking one person out of a lane could reduce throughput from approximately 390 to 305 passengers per lane per hour. Covering the gap would require a supernumerary (an extra officer beyond the team) at penalty rates Certis could not charge to its client.

“If your start time in the roster is 7.30, if your start time in the roster is 6, you need to turn up at 7.30 or 6, otherwise the team is short,” the manager told the hearing.

The Deputy President found each reason “rational and sound, and related to the Respondent’s operational requirements and obligations”. He found the worker’s position was that “notwithstanding the reasonable business grounds, her requests should nonetheless somehow be accommodated”.

What was not before the Commission

The worker’s allegations of a systemic, bad faith course of conduct by Certis were held “not relevant” to the application. The Deputy President said compliance with s.65A(3) is assessed at the time of each refusal, here July and December 2025.

He made an order under s.65C(1)(b) that the grounds on which Certis refused both requests be taken to have been reasonable business grounds. Although Certis did not respond to the first request within 21 days, the Deputy President was satisfied that it met the requirements of s.65A(3).

At a glance

  • Parties: An aviation screening officer and Certis Security Australia
  • Citation: [2026] FWC 4115, Deputy President Cross, 22 October 2026
  • Section: Fair Work Act 2009, ss.65A(3), 65A(5), 65B and 65C(1)(b)
  • Outcome: Refusals of the 4 June 2025 and 5 December 2025 requests taken to be on reasonable business grounds
  • Who it affects: Employers and carers in rostered, peak-driven workplaces

The hearing was held in Sydney on 27 March 2026. The worker was represented by the United Workers Union until 13 October 2025 and then represented herself. Certis was represented by its General Counsel, Sarah Edwards.

Source: [2026] FWC 4115

General information only. OnNotice reports developments in Australian industrial relations, human resources and workplace law. This article is for education purposes only and is not intended to form professional advice. Always confirm against the primary source and seek specific advice relating to your circumstances.

Share this storyLinkedInWhatsAppTeamsFacebookX

Keep reading