A chief executive who invoiced a Melbourne AI startup $20,833.33 a month through his own company was an independent contractor and not an employee, the Fair Work Commission has found, dismissing his general protections claim (a claim that an employer took adverse action against a person for exercising a workplace right) for want of jurisdiction.
Commissioner Perica held that because the applicant was not an employee of NeuraGPT Pty Ltd, he could not have been dismissed, and dismissal is a necessary element of an application under s.365 of the Fair Work Act 2009. The decision is [2026] FWC 2759, dated 22 July 2026.
At a glance
- Parties: The applicant, a former chief executive, and NeuraGPT Pty Ltd (formerly Mind Body GPT Pty Ltd)
- Citation: [2026] FWC 2759
- Section: s.365 (general protections dismissal); s.15AA (ordinary meaning of employee), Fair Work Act 2009
- Outcome: Application dismissed for want of jurisdiction; the applicant was found to be an independent contractor
- Who it affects: Startups engaging executives through corporate vehicles, and workers contracting through their own companies
The applicant, a technology executive with 40 years of industry experience, an MBA and a previous role as a startup CEO, was approached in July 2023 by the man who later became NeuraGPT’s acting chief executive. In May 2024 the applicant’s company signed an Independent Contractor Agreement with the startup for $250,000 a year plus GST, paid by monthly invoice. He took the title of CEO.
The contract contained an unusual term negotiated in by the applicant: a leave credit of 2.5 days a month, with accrued but untaken days payable at $1,000 a day on termination. The applicant sought superannuation on top of the fee but did not get it, telling the Commission he “ended up compromising, essentially”.
From mid-December 2024 NeuraGPT stopped paying. With $73,447.27 in invoices outstanding, the applicant’s company issued a default notice on 11 March 2025 and a notice of termination on 19 March 2025, both signed by the applicant as its director and both invoking the contract’s terms. On 7 April 2025 he applied to the Commission, alleging adverse action for complaints about unpaid remuneration, sham contracting (disguising an employment relationship as an independent contract) and constructive dismissal.
He worked full time and exclusively for NeuraGPT, was presented to the world as its CEO, was paid a fixed monthly amount with leave accruals, and had no control over the company’s finances. The acting chief executive controlled all significant expenditure and directed which opportunities the applicant pursued and how. The contract, he said, was a “sham to avoid obligations”.
The relationship was a genuinely negotiated contract for services with the applicant’s company, which invoiced monthly with GST and no tax withheld. The acting chief executive said everyone at the startup, himself included, was a contractor: “It had some debt financing that was contingent upon, interestingly, invoicing and making sure you were a contractor. That was the only way it was getting funded at the time.”
The applicant was not an employee. Some indicia pointed to employment, but the character of the relationship in the contract “was based on a robust negotiation and amounted to a compromise between sophisticated bargaining parties”, and the applicant had relied on its terms to end the relationship.
The Commissioner applied s.15AA, which was enacted in response to the High Court’s decisions in Personnel Contracting and Jamsek and requires the Commission to look beyond the written contract.
For the purposes of this Act, whether an individual is an employee of a person within the ordinary meaning of that expression, or whether a person is an employer of an individual within the ordinary meaning of that expression, is to be determined by ascertaining the real substance, practical reality and true nature of the relationship between the individual and the person.
Several factors pointed towards employment, the Commissioner found: the degree of control the acting chief executive exercised over finances and the applicant’s work, the applicant’s practical inability to work for others, his presentation to the outside world as chief executive, and remuneration for his time only with expenses reimbursed.
Against that, the applicant had chosen his corporate vehicle as the contracting party partly because it had “tax losses”, had himself negotiated in the leave credit and the limited warranties he later cited as employment indicators, was paid on invoice without tax withheld, and held a contractual right to delegate, which the Commission described as a “strong indicator” of contracting. His evidence was that he would have preferred employment but “I wanted to do the job, so I kind of went along with it.”
The manner of termination weighed heavily. Commissioner Perica found that, having enforced his company’s rights under the agreement and ended it on its own terms, the applicant could not then deny the character the agreement gave the relationship. The applicant, the Commissioner said, “cannot have it both ways”:
“… he either relies on the Contract terms, or he asserts the terms are a ‘sham’.”
The dispute may not end at the Commission. NeuraGPT told the Commission the contract’s alternative dispute resolution process had already been invoked, and that it had drafted Supreme Court of Victoria proceedings against the applicant seeking approximately $2.2 million in damages for alleged misleading and deceptive conduct, negligence and fraud.
Source: [2026] FWC 2759
General information only. OnNotice reports developments in Australian industrial relations, human resources and workplace law. This article is for education purposes only and is not intended to form professional advice. Always confirm against the primary source and seek specific advice relating to your circumstances.