Courier business ordered to re-engage contractor replaced by text message during her leave

A courier contractor was unfairly terminated when she was told by text that her Australia Post delivery run had a new full-time driver, the Fair Work Commission has found. Commissioner McKinnon ordered a new services contract rather than compensation, despite the contractor’s submission that the relationship was not workable.

4 min read
Fair Work Commission
Share this storyLinkedInWhatsAppTeamsFacebookX

On 5 February 2026, the day before a contractor was due back from leave, the owner of BESB Couriers sent her a text message: “I have managed to find a fulltime driver for the Toukley area, Thanks again sam”. That message brought the contractor’s services contract to an end, and the Fair Work Commission has found the termination was unfair.

Commissioner McKinnon found there was no valid reason for the termination and that the processes in the Road Transport Industry Termination Code were not followed. The Code sets out a process a road transport business must follow when it is considering ending a contractor’s services contract. The Commissioner ordered BESB Couriers to enter into a new contract with the contractor instead of paying compensation.

How the run was lost

BESB Couriers delivers parcels under a contract with Australia Post. From 12 November 2025 the contractor ran the Toukley delivery area on the Central Coast of New South Wales, working through a company she owned with her husband. She had done irregular work for BESB Couriers through that company over about four years. The company had given notice on 28 September 2025 in an email that accused the business of “stupid childish games”, and the arrangement ended on 3 October 2025. About a month later the contractor sought work again.

BESB Couriers supplied hire vans at no charge after the contractor’s van broke down on 30 November 2025 and again on 2 January 2026. It accepted her holiday from 12 January to 6 February 2026, although three other drivers were also unavailable. On 9 January 2026 a staff member told her there were no plans to find someone else.

During her leave another driver covered the run and drew no delivery complaints. The contractor, by contrast, had attracted several complaints over a short period, all of which BESB Couriers had dealt with internally without issuing warnings. The business chose to keep the replacement on the Toukley run and give the contractor different work.

The contractor replied to the 5 February message: “I want my job back simple.” The next day her husband confronted the owner at the depot, raising his voice. He then told the contractor she no longer had work. Neither side contacted the other after that, and BESB Couriers did not offer her any more work until after she had started proceedings.

BESB Couriers argued

that the contractor was a “no show” on 9 February 2026, and that it had planned to give her work in a different area and reissue a subcontractor agreement for signing.

The contractor said

that she had been assured she would keep the Toukley run after her leave, and submitted that an ongoing relationship with BESB Couriers was not workable.

Commissioner McKinnon found

that she was not a no-show, because “the only clear advice” from BESB Couriers was that she had been replaced, and that a new contract would not be inappropriate.

An unwitting termination

The Commissioner found that BESB Couriers had never actively considered ending the contract, so the Code process did not apply. The contractor received no warnings and was given no opportunity to show cause before the contract ended.

The complaints had been resolved without disciplinary action. The depot confrontation did not involve the contractor. “At best”, the Commissioner said, she had not signed her contract, which put BESB Couriers at risk of breaching its obligations to Australia Post.

The Commissioner observed that BESB Couriers is a small business “operating under considerable strain” to meet the staffing needs of its Australia Post contract. Its limited resources were likely to have contributed to “its unwitting termination of the services contract”.

A new contract, not compensation

Under the regime, compensation can be ordered only where a new contract would be inappropriate and compensation is appropriate in all the circumstances. BESB Couriers had repeatedly confirmed that work was available. The Commissioner noted the relationship had been described “in almost familial terms” and had survived the October 2025 termination.

“With the right attitude and improved efforts at communication on both sides, the relationship is capable of being restored for the benefit of both parties,” the Commissioner said.

The contractor applied on 24 February 2026 under s 536LU of the Fair Work Act 2009. It was not disputed that she was a regulated road transport contractor who had worked for a road transport business for at least six months. In an earlier decision, [2026] FWC 2769, the Commissioner found she was terminated on 5 February 2026.

The new contract is to be with the contractor in her personal capacity, not her company. Separate orders will issue. The Commission found the termination unfair even though BESB Couriers had not set out to end the contract.

At a glance

  • Parties: A courier contractor v BESB Couriers Pty Ltd
  • Citation: [2026] FWC 4143, Commissioner McKinnon, Sydney, 26 October 2026
  • Section: Fair Work Act 2009, s 536LU and s 536LR; Road Transport Industry Termination Code
  • Outcome: Termination unfair; new services contract to be entered into
  • Who it affects: Road transport businesses and regulated road transport contractors

Late filing decides more of these cases than fairness does. Across the 91 unfair deactivation decisions OnNotice coded to late July, 71 never reached the merits, with the 21 day time limit the most common wall.

Source: [2026] FWC 4143

General information only. OnNotice reports developments in Australian industrial relations, human resources and workplace law. This article is for education purposes only and is not intended to form professional advice. Always confirm against the primary source and seek specific advice relating to your circumstances.

Share this storyLinkedInWhatsAppTeamsFacebookX

Keep reading