A casual residential care officer looked into a resident’s bedroom in the early afternoon and saw what he took to be the man napping. It was a bunched-up doona. A community access support worker had already collected the resident from the house. The lapse covered the period from about 1:30 pm to 2:45 pm on 22 September 2023.
That was the third of three allegations the Department of Child Safety, Seniors and Disability Services substantiated against the officer, covering shifts on 20, 21 and 22 September 2023. The Queensland Industrial Relations Commission has now confirmed those findings. Industrial Commissioner McLennan held that the department’s decision to find grounds for discipline under s 91(1)(a) of the Public Sector Act 2022 (Qld) was fair and reasonable.
engaged in repeated unsatisfactory performance or serious under performance of the employee’s duties, including, for example, by performing duties carelessly, incompetently or inefficiently.
Three shifts, three allegations
The officer, classified OO3, had worked for the department since 18 May 2015. He was based at the Redcliffe Service Centre in accommodation support and respite services.
The first allegation was that on 20 September 2023 he did not engage with a resident in his care and kept using his personal phone while a clinician was assessing her and her family were visiting. The resident’s mother sat in a pool of urine on the couch. The officer accepted that she told him to “get off my phone and go clean the couch”. He said he had only been checking messages after time outside in the sun with another resident.
The second allegation was that on 21 September 2023 he breached a resident’s Mealtime Management Plan (a specialist’s written instructions on how a person at risk of choking must be fed). At about 8:30 am he handed the resident a piece of toast to eat while being driven to an outing. The plan required soft food cut into small pieces, stated “NO DRY FOODS, NO CRUMBLY FOODS”, and required the resident to eat seated at a table and observed. The plan was displayed on the fridge. The officer admitted to an acting team leader that he had not read it.
At the time of all three incidents the officer was on a Performance Improvement Plan, which began on 1 September 2023. It followed an incident on 11 July 2023 in which a resident in his care was seriously bruised in a fall. He had also received a caution letter in 2018 that included a warning about adhering to mealtime plans.
The officer said the allegations shifted; the Commission found they had not
that the family member was more likely angry “because she had just sat in urine” than because of his phone use. He said the toast allegation had been reframed after his time to respond had passed, and that the department “never sought any information that might portray the events differently”. On the third allegation, he said napping was “a known behaviour” for the resident, that he had checked on him several times, and that the support worker failed to tell him the resident was leaving.
that, whether or not the resident usually napped, the officer was obliged to check on a person he believed was lying still in bed at midday. It said the finding that he failed to check for 60 minutes “is the only conclusion that can be drawn, given that [Mr A] was later found to have been absent from the residence for that time.” (The decision refers to the resident as Mr A.) It said the support worker’s conduct was not condoned and had been taken into account.
that the wording of all three allegations was “exactly the same” in the initial letter and the final decision, and that the claim the department never sought his side was “a baseless proposition”. There were no procedural flaws.
On the phone allegation, the officer said the department never defined an inappropriate amount of time on a phone. The Commissioner said the answer was “rather straightforward”: “not at all”, while a clinician assessment and family visit was under way.
The Commissioner said “it really does not matter ‘how’ he was using the personal mobile phone, the point is that he was supposed to be properly attending to the work he was being paid to perform.”
On the toast, the Commissioner said whether the resident had eaten breakfast first “does not ameliorate the insurmountable default” that the plan was not followed. The Commissioner described the officer’s initial response, that the matter had already been resolved by a team leader, as “a rather cavalier response” on a duty of care to a vulnerable person.
A bed checked from the doorway
The officer said he was helping another resident with toileting in a bathroom where a knock at the door could not be heard. The delegate noted that the officer’s own incident report placed the toileting at about 1:30 pm to 1:50 pm, and that he offered no evidence of other duties that would have stopped him engaging with the resident. She found that after seeing the doona he took no further steps to check for a further 60 minutes. The absence was a Category Level 2 major incident under the department’s critical incident policy.
The Commissioner found that if the officer had spoken to the resident or stepped into the room, “he would have discovered it was a doona, not a person”. A known habit of daytime napping did not relieve a residential care officer of the duty to make sure that someone lying motionless was all right, the Commissioner found.
At a glance
- Parties: A casual residential care officer v State of Queensland (Department of Child Safety, Seniors and Disability Services)
- Citation: [2026] QIRC 341
- Section: Public Sector Act 2022 (Qld) s 91(1)(a); Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld) s 562B, s 562C(1)(a)
- Outcome: Disciplinary finding decision confirmed; decision delivered 23 October 2026, reasons 26 October 2026
- Who it affects: Queensland public sector employees appealing disciplinary findings
Termination still to be decided
The appeal was decided on the papers. Orders issued on 23 October 2026 and reasons followed on 26 October 2026. The appeal was filed on 19 February 2024, against a decision dated 30 January 2024 that the officer received on 2 February 2024.
The Commissioner reviewed the decision under s 562B(3) of the Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld), which asks whether it was fair and reasonable, applying the ordinary meaning of those words set out by the Industrial Court in State of Queensland (Queensland Health) v Hume [2024] ICQ 3. The appeal was not a rehearing. The question was whether the delegate could be “reasonably satisfied” on the balance of probabilities (more likely than not), with the strength of evidence required rising with the seriousness of the allegation under Briginshaw v Briginshaw.
The department’s proposed penalty, “termination of [his] casual employment”, was not part of the appeal because no penalty had been determined. The officer must first be given the chance to respond to it. Under s 451, the Commission also ordered that all submissions in the matter be “withheld from release or search absolutely”.
Source: [2026] QIRC 341
General information only. OnNotice reports developments in Australian industrial relations, human resources and workplace law. This article is for education purposes only and is not intended to form professional advice. Always confirm against the primary source and seek specific advice relating to your circumstances.