A head of operations who resigned from Bondi Born after being told that “anyone with a brain” would know a particular technical term was not dismissed, the Fair Work Commission has found.
Commissioner Matheson dismissed the application on 12 October 2026. The claim was made under s.365 of the Fair Work Act 2009, which allows the Commission to deal with general protections disputes involving dismissal. Because only a person who has been dismissed can bring such an application, whether the worker had been dismissed had to be resolved first, at a determinative conference held by video on 7 July 2026.
The worker accepted that she resigned, and relied on s.386(1)(b) of the Act, under which a resignation is a dismissal only if the employee “was forced to do so because of conduct, or a course of conduct, engaged in by his or her employer”. Bondi Born Pty Ltd objected on the basis that she had resigned voluntarily, and argued in the alternative that if she had been dismissed, the application was made out of time.
At a glance
- Parties: A former head of operations v Bondi Born Pty Ltd
- Citation: [2026] FWC 3896
- Sections: s.365 and s.386(1)(b), Fair Work Act 2009
- Decision maker: Commissioner Matheson, Sydney, 12 October 2026
- Outcome: Applicant found not to have been dismissed; application dismissed
- Who it affects: Employees who resign and later claim they were forced out, and the employers they claim it against
The promised support resigned on 30 January
The applicant began full-time employment on 12 January 2026 as Head of Operations, a role covering supply-chain operations, inventory systems, warehouse operations and customer service. She gave evidence that at interview she was told the role would be supported by casual warehouse staff and by an existing part-time employee who would be moved to full-time hours.
That permanent customer service assistant resigned on 30 January 2026. A Philippines based administrative worker resigned without notice in mid-February 2026. The applicant carried out two full stocktakes, in February and March 2026, each of roughly 6,000 items.
Five staff were rostered for the February stocktake. On 11 February 2026 the founder, Dale McCarthy, emailed the applicant saying it was “the highest casuals wages bill for a week that I’ve every (sic) paid” while thanking her for getting the stocktake done quickly, and said the warehouse needed to return to a normal level of casuals. On 10 March 2026 the applicant asked for two additional workers and was told the next day that the budget would not stretch to it. On 23 and 24 March 2026 she warned that reliance on casual staff was a risk to the business. The founder replied on 24 March 2026 that she would advertise for permanent staff that day.
- 12 Jan 2026 Applicant commences as Head of Operations.
- 30 Jan 2026 The permanent customer service assistant resigns.
- 10 Mar 2026 Applicant requests two additional workers.
- 11 Mar 2026 Request refused on budget grounds.
- 24 Mar 2026 Founder says she will advertise for permanent staff.
- 26 Mar 2026 Applicant resigns by email.
- 3 Apr 2026 Employment ends.
- 7 Jul 2026 Determinative conference held by video.
- 12 Oct 2026 Decision issued.
The applicant resigned by email on 26 March 2026, giving 3 April 2026 as her final day and attributing the decision to “the unprofessional communication and the prevalent blaming culture within the office” and to the “anyone with a brain” remark made that morning. She handed over the office keys and left the premises at 3pm the following day, and provided a medical certificate covering 27 March to 3 April 2026. Commissioner Matheson found the employment ended on 3 April 2026, with notice, accrued annual leave, superannuation and the Good Friday public holiday paid.
A management style the Commission called critical and unsupportive
Commissioner Matheson accepted that there were occasions when the applicant was blamed for problems that were not her doing. An email sent to a colleague late on 5 March 2026, and copied to the applicant, said there were “a bunch of issues with inventory”, that the applicant was “still struggling to get on top of inventory and dispatching” and that it was, “Frankly, a bit of a mess”. Emails between 13 and 16 March 2026 used capitalisation that the Commissioner found “connoted shouting and would have been unpleasant for the Applicant to read and embarrassing in circumstances where her colleagues were copied in”. The founder apologised on 16 March 2026 after the applicant established that the stock in question had arrived in December 2025, before her employment began.
The Commissioner also dealt with repeated references to English language ability, including a direction on 16 March 2026 that the applicant take calls on the customer service phone because nobody in her team had strong English. Commissioner Matheson said there did “not appear to be any clear deficiencies in the Applicant’s capacity to communicate in English”, and that the suggestion of language difficulties “could reasonably be considered as offensive and belittling by the Applicant”, adding that the founder “should reflect on how her communications have been perceived”.
On the “anyone with a brain” remark, the Commissioner found it was “another example of Ms McCarthy delivering her criticism in a way that was not constructive and offered no guidance to the Applicant”, and that her blunt manner of communication, lack of constructive feedback and management style “presented as critical and unsupportive of a new employee”.
Why that did not make the resignation a dismissal
that a course of conduct left her no real choice. She pointed to the employer’s failure to provide enough permanent staffing after she had put her concerns about operational risk in writing; the informal shifting of part of her warehouse responsibilities and the management of her casual staff to another manager between 10 and 11 March 2026; written directions that referred to her first language and to her team’s English; criticism of her sent to colleagues and to an external vendor over problems later traced to system faults or to the employer’s own errors; and the remark on 26 March 2026. She submitted that no reasonable person in her position would have been expected to continue, and that because the conduct came from the sole director and chief executive there was no more senior person to complain to.
that the resignation was voluntary and unsolicited, and “a complete surprise”. The founder gave evidence that the applicant was employed during a very busy period in which the business was filling international wholesale orders to strict delivery deadlines, so ending her employment would have made no sense. The employer said it had issued no ultimatum, that nothing suggested the applicant expected to be dismissed, and that none of its actions could be read as a step towards dismissal or as designed to push her out. It argued the legal threshold is extremely high, distinguishing Mohazab v Dick Smith Electronics Pty Ltd (No 2) and Bupa Aged Care Australia Pty Ltd v Tavassoli as cases turning on accusations of theft.
that the employer “faced resourcing challenges due to unplanned resignations and absences”, that the founder had committed by 24 March 2026 to advertise for permanent staff, and that the applicant resigned on 26 March 2026 before a full-time employee had been secured. On the warehouse layout issue, the Commissioner found another employee had simply been asked to help out while the applicant was busy, and was “not persuaded that there was any intention to vary the scope of the Applicant’s role”.
Applying the test restated by the Full Bench in Bupa Aged Care Australia Pty Ltd t/a Bupa Aged Care Mosman v Shahin Tavassoli [2017] FWCFB 3941, the Commissioner asked whether the employer “engaged in the conduct with the intention of bringing the employment to an end”, or whether termination “was the probable result of the employer’s conduct such that the employee had no effective or real choice but to resign”. The decision also set out the Full Bench’s observation in Doumit v ABB Engineering Construction Pty Ltd about the “narrow line” separating conduct that leaves an employee no real choice from conduct that does not.
“In the circumstances of this matter, and when the Respondent’s conduct is considered objectively and as a whole, more is required to convert the resignation into a termination at the initiative of the employer.” Commissioner Matheson, [2026] FWC 3896
Commissioner Matheson wrote: “I accept that the Applicant’s workplace was an unpleasant one and that her experience there as a new employee has had a negative impact on her.” The Commissioner found the evidence did not establish an intention on the employer’s part to bring the employment to an end, and that the resignation “was not an outcome that it had foreseen or intended”. A witness statement from a former employee who worked for the respondent for one month between December 2025 and January 2026 was filed, but he was not available to be cross-examined; the Commissioner assessed his account of a workplace short on support for new employees as consistent with what the applicant had experienced.
Commissioner Matheson found that the applicant was not dismissed within the meaning of s.386(1) of the Act and dismissed the s.365 application.
Source: [2026] FWC 3896
General information only. OnNotice reports developments in Australian industrial relations, human resources and workplace law. This article is for education purposes only and is not intended to form professional advice. Always confirm against the primary source and seek specific advice relating to your circumstances.