BlueCare nurses’ 5% and 10% above-award pay link ended at agreement expiry, missing July 2026 rise

BlueCare does not have to pass the July 2026 award increase on to assistants in nursing and enrolled nurses under an agreement that has passed its nominal expiry date, the Fair Work Commission has found. The QNMU argued the agreed percentages above the award kept applying while the agreement stayed in force. Commissioner Spencer found…

6 min read
Fair Work Commission
Share this storyLinkedInWhatsAppTeamsFacebookX

Assistants in nursing (AINs) and enrolled nurses (ENs) at BlueCare are not entitled under their enterprise agreement to have their pay lifted in line with the July 2026 award increase. The Fair Work Commission found that the agreement’s link to award rates ended on its nominal expiry date of 14 May 2026. The nominal expiry date is the end date set in an agreement. After it passes, the agreement keeps operating until it is replaced or terminated.

The Australian Nursing and Midwifery Federation (Queensland Nurses and Midwives’ Union), known as the QNMU, brought the dispute against UnitingCare Queensland Limited, trading as BlueCare, under s.739 of the Fair Work Act 2009. That section allows the Commission to arbitrate a dispute where an agreement’s dispute procedure permits it. Two other unions covered by the agreement, the Health Services Union and the United Workers Union, backed the QNMU’s application but did not ask to be heard.

A percentage above the award, not a fixed dollar rate

The BlueCare Nursing Employees Enterprise Agreement 2024 was approved on 7 May 2024. Clause 6.2 sets AIN base rates at “at least 5% above” the rate payable under the relevant award, “as varied from time”. Clause 6.3 sets ENs at least 10% above the award and Enrolled Nurse (Advanced Skills) at least 13% above. Registered nurses are treated differently. Their rates rise by set percentages on set dates: 3% from the first full pay period after 1 July 2024 and 2% from the first full pay period after 1 July 2025.

BlueCare accepted that the AIN and EN rates were tied to award rates and that award rates rose in July 2026. It disputed that the tie survived the nominal expiry date. The parties jointly asked for an urgent decision. Bargaining for a replacement agreement has started, and the union said certainty was needed about the wage rates that bargaining was starting from.

The QNMU argued

that the agreed percentages above the award were embedded in the agreement and continued while it remained in force. It relied heavily on the phrase “at all times” in the Schedule 1 wage tables. It sought an order requiring BlueCare to pay the higher rates, within seven days, for all work performed from 7 July 2026, and to keep paying them after that.

BlueCare argued

that increases by reference to the award accrued “only up to the nominal expiry date, and not beyond”. It also submitted: “The Agreement makes no clear statement as to whether the link to (an agreed percentage above) Award rates is maintained only during the nominal term, or is intended to extend beyond”. It pointed to the separate July 2024 and July 2025 columns in Schedule 1. It also argued that the union’s reading would give AINs and ENs ongoing rises that registered nurses would not receive.

Commissioner Spencer found

that the plain and ordinary meaning of the provisions “leads to the outcome that no further wage increases were to occur beyond the nominal expiry date”, apart from the statutory protection that applies if agreement rates fall below the award. The Commissioner adopted BlueCare’s arguments and contextual matters, and answered both questions for arbitration “No”.

What employees were told before the vote

Both sides relied on extrinsic material, meaning documents outside the agreement’s text. The QNMU relied on bargaining drafts, tracked changes and the comments of bargaining representatives. BlueCare’s first draft, emailed to the union on 15 December 2023, included a clause 6.2.2 beginning “Up to and including the nominal expiry date of this Agreement”, which required AIN base rates to remain 5% above the award, and an equivalent clause for ENs at 10%. The union’s industrial officer, Kevin Crank, replied seeking to have those clauses deleted.

BlueCare relied on the frequently asked questions document it gave employees before the vote. That document said “Assistants in Nursing will be paid and maintained at 5% above the Nursing Award for the life of the agreement”. It also projected that the agreement would expire around May 2026.

The Commissioner applied the Full Bench’s principles in AMWU v Berri Pty Ltd [2017] FWCFB 3005. One of those principles holds that what employees were told can carry more weight than the positions taken in bargaining. The Commissioner found that the access materials “clearly support the argument that the wage increases were only to occur for the life of the agreement that is the nominal term of the Agreement”.

An acknowledged anomaly the Commission would not rewrite

The Commissioner noted that Mr Crank, as the union’s bargaining representative, “would not have intended that the wage increases for nurses engaged under the cover of this Agreement, effectively freeze” at the nominal expiry date. The decision also identified an anomaly in the union’s reading, because AIN and EN rates could keep rising past registered nurse rates. The Commissioner observed that “the parties are the architects of the wording in the agreement”, and quoted the second Berri principle: “The task of interpreting an agreement does not involve rewriting the agreement to achieve what might be regarded as a fair or just outcome.”

The Commissioner distinguished cases where pay rises continued after nominal expiry, including the Full Court’s decision in Qube Logistics (Rail) Pty Ltd v Australian Rail, Tram and Bus Industry Union [2021] FCAFC 83. Those agreements turned on wording about increases on each anniversary. The BlueCare provisions name two dates and do not refer to anniversaries. BlueCare also pointed to s.226 of the Act. That section, as amended, now sets stricter tests for terminating an agreement after its nominal expiry date. BlueCare argued the amended provision formed part of the context for interpreting the agreement.

One missed round, and a statutory floor

The Commissioner observed that only one round of increases, July 2026, has been missed, and that the parties “have the immediate ability to negotiate taking this into account”. Current rates are above the award. If bargaining runs long, clause 11.4.2 of the agreement and s.206 of the Act require base rates to be no less than award rates.

BlueCare was granted legal representation under s.596(2)(a), over the union’s objection, on the basis that the complexity of the dispute meant representation would make the matter more efficient to deal with. Jamie Wells, a partner of Mills Oakley, appeared for BlueCare. Mr Crank appeared for the union. The hearing was held by video on 15 October 2026, and the decision was issued in Brisbane on 23 October 2026.

Because both questions were answered in the negative, the Commission did not need to consider the orders the union sought. The parties are continuing to bargain for a replacement agreement.

At a glance

  • Parties: Australian Nursing and Midwifery Federation (QNMU) v UnitingCare Queensland Limited t/a BlueCare
  • Citation: [2026] FWC 4145, Commissioner Spencer, 23 October 2026
  • Section: s.739 Fair Work Act 2009; clauses 6.2, 6.3 and Schedule 1 of the BlueCare Nursing Employees Enterprise Agreement 2024
  • Outcome: No obligation to pay increases linked to the award after the nominal expiry date of 14 May 2026; orders not considered
  • Who it affects: AINs and ENs covered by the agreement

Source: [2026] FWC 4145

General information only. OnNotice reports developments in Australian industrial relations, human resources and workplace law. This article is for education purposes only and is not intended to form professional advice. Always confirm against the primary source and seek specific advice relating to your circumstances.

Share this storyLinkedInWhatsAppTeamsFacebookX

Keep reading